I'd be up for discussing a points cap again.
Looking at what has been discussed so far in this thread http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,108074.0.html thinking that we should set out a list in preparation for discussion prion to this 2017 seasons completion.1: Removal of Rookie List, meaning squad of 46 players. Saying if this gets up will also mean removal of the LTI thread also.2: National Draft rule 2hr & 24hr remains, but for the first round, if it goes over, you get the next allocated AFL drafted player. Also if you log on prior to the next coach pick, you can change the allocated pick.3. Points Cap, tho previously discussed & defeated. 4. Finalise squads after AFL Draft, meaning if players (who are currently on a AXV list) are delisted and get picked up. AXV Clubs will know before finalising.5. Bidding process for returning AFL players, returning players who have been out of the AFL system for at least one year. They will not be on a current AXV list. The Club who last owned that player will get to match any bid prior to the AXV Nat draft. 6. Team Submission, (A) Keep the current naming of team. (B) Submit the traditional way & as well use UF. 7. Players Positions, (A) Maintain the current Virtual Sports. (B) Adopt UF's positions at start of the season.**Note saying this gets voted in would then require another vote on to "Allow In-Season Updates."8. Play through the bye rounds, Play through or have this off.
Should we maybe wait until the end of the season before we vote on rule changes? People's opinions often change during the season over these kind of rules.Also, I believe that we should only be allowing one vote per club, rather than coach. It seems unfair that teams with co-coaches get two votes regarding how the rule change potentially impacts their team.
Quote from: BB67th on March 27, 2017, 05:21:54 PMShould we maybe wait until the end of the season before we vote on rule changes? People's opinions often change during the season over these kind of rules.Also, I believe that we should only be allowing one vote per club, rather than coach. It seems unfair that teams with co-coaches get two votes regarding how the rule change potentially impacts their team.what?? never knew this was the case. That isnt very fair.
Quote from: SydneyRox on March 27, 2017, 05:30:39 PMQuote from: BB67th on March 27, 2017, 05:21:54 PMShould we maybe wait until the end of the season before we vote on rule changes? People's opinions often change during the season over these kind of rules.Also, I believe that we should only be allowing one vote per club, rather than coach. It seems unfair that teams with co-coaches get two votes regarding how the rule change potentially impacts their team.what?? never knew this was the case. That isnt very fair.In the past I believe we've only had one vote per team, but in the pm nas sent out he mentioned 20 coaches voting including co-coaches.
Quote from: BB67th on March 27, 2017, 05:40:30 PMQuote from: SydneyRox on March 27, 2017, 05:30:39 PMQuote from: BB67th on March 27, 2017, 05:21:54 PMShould we maybe wait until the end of the season before we vote on rule changes? People's opinions often change during the season over these kind of rules.Also, I believe that we should only be allowing one vote per club, rather than coach. It seems unfair that teams with co-coaches get two votes regarding how the rule change potentially impacts their team.what?? never knew this was the case. That isnt very fair.In the past I believe we've only had one vote per team, but in the pm nas sent out he mentioned 20 coaches voting including co-coaches.IMO, some of the rules need to be in place prior to the start of the trading / drafts so that we're ready to go. Some can be held off till later when the season is completed.Yes, should & will be 1 vote per team. Would expect the teams that share the duties vote accordingly & submit 1 vote for their team.The 20 PM's were sent so that to promote discussion between them. My mistake to not include wording for 1 vote per team.
Quote from: nas on March 27, 2017, 05:45:55 PMQuote from: BB67th on March 27, 2017, 05:40:30 PMQuote from: SydneyRox on March 27, 2017, 05:30:39 PMQuote from: BB67th on March 27, 2017, 05:21:54 PMShould we maybe wait until the end of the season before we vote on rule changes? People's opinions often change during the season over these kind of rules.Also, I believe that we should only be allowing one vote per club, rather than coach. It seems unfair that teams with co-coaches get two votes regarding how the rule change potentially impacts their team.what?? never knew this was the case. That isnt very fair.In the past I believe we've only had one vote per team, but in the pm nas sent out he mentioned 20 coaches voting including co-coaches.IMO, some of the rules need to be in place prior to the start of the trading / drafts so that we're ready to go. Some can be held off till later when the season is completed.Yes, should & will be 1 vote per team. Would expect the teams that share the duties vote accordingly & submit 1 vote for their team.The 20 PM's were sent so that to promote discussion between them. My mistake to not include wording for 1 vote per team.I still don't see the point in voting on 2018 rules after round 1 of 2017. We can vote towards the end of the season if need be, but there will be coaches who change their minds on some things between now and then.
Quote from: BB67th on March 27, 2017, 05:52:13 PMQuote from: nas on March 27, 2017, 05:45:55 PMQuote from: BB67th on March 27, 2017, 05:40:30 PMQuote from: SydneyRox on March 27, 2017, 05:30:39 PMQuote from: BB67th on March 27, 2017, 05:21:54 PMShould we maybe wait until the end of the season before we vote on rule changes? People's opinions often change during the season over these kind of rules.Also, I believe that we should only be allowing one vote per club, rather than coach. It seems unfair that teams with co-coaches get two votes regarding how the rule change potentially impacts their team.what?? never knew this was the case. That isnt very fair.In the past I believe we've only had one vote per team, but in the pm nas sent out he mentioned 20 coaches voting including co-coaches.IMO, some of the rules need to be in place prior to the start of the trading / drafts so that we're ready to go. Some can be held off till later when the season is completed.Yes, should & will be 1 vote per team. Would expect the teams that share the duties vote accordingly & submit 1 vote for their team.The 20 PM's were sent so that to promote discussion between them. My mistake to not include wording for 1 vote per team.I still don't see the point in voting on 2018 rules after round 1 of 2017. We can vote towards the end of the season if need be, but there will be coaches who change their minds on some things between now and then.If thy change their minds and enough agree then we can just do a re-vote.It is always nice to get things addressed nice and early. I don't see any issue in voting early and addressing things then when they come up.