FanFooty Forum

AFL fantasy competitions => General Supercoach => Players & Trades in SC => Topic started by: tommy10 on March 19, 2020, 04:01:45 PM

Title: Who to field thread
Post by: tommy10 on March 19, 2020, 04:01:45 PM
Obviously dependant on teams

Out of the rookies playing that we know, who are you fielding Round 1?

Def: ZBT/Ash, Brander/Williams possibly - assuming they all are selected and playing
Mids: Rowell, Pickett, Green - is anyone putting Pickett as emg to see how he goes. If 70+ and then select someone like Hibberd/Sharp/Mahony/Budarick on field as a non-playing rookie?
Fwds: Georgiades, Brander, Taylor/Sturt//Davis/Bedford - thinking Georgiades and Taylor assuming the latter plays.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: LordSneeze on March 19, 2020, 04:09:52 PM
Im waiting for teams before making any final decisions.

Considering Pickett on bench as E, but will depend on who else is available and If there will be a donut or not.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Rusty00 on March 19, 2020, 10:01:05 PM
Well Pickett has given those that have him with the E the age old question as to whether to purposely pick a donut this week to get his score :-X
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Gavdroid on March 19, 2020, 10:08:27 PM
Well Pickett has given those that have him with the E the age old question as to whether to purposely pick a donut this week to get his score :-X

Probably an opportunity to still pick Steven as a mid and have Budarick on the fwd bench
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: LordSneeze on March 19, 2020, 10:18:44 PM
Well Pickett has given those that have him with the E the age old question as to whether to purposely pick a donut this week to get his score :-X

Probably an opportunity to still pick Steven as a mid and have Budarick on the fwd bench
If it was me id consider Serong. He was close to being picked by hadn't trained enough.
Other options would be Starcevich or Robertson if either aren't selected for Brisbane

Not many good mid rookies to start so I don't see a huge issue with picking a donut there.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: RaisyDaisy on March 19, 2020, 10:21:16 PM
Well Pickett has given those that have him with the E the age old question as to whether to purposely pick a donut this week to get his score :-X

Probably an opportunity to still pick Steven as a mid and have Budarick on the fwd bench
If it was me id consider Serong. He was close to being picked by hadn't trained enough.
Other options would be Starcevich or Robertson if either aren't selected for Brisbane

Not many good mid rookies to start so I don't see a huge issue with picking a donut there.

Yep, if Dev Robbo doesn't get named I'll still start him at M11. If not, Starcevich/Mahony

We basically have 2 trades every round this year, so won't ever need M11. Yeah it delays cash gen a little, but points gained via looping will be worth more

EDIT: Starting Steven an option too, as Gavdroid suggested. Might consider that

Either way, I'm banking Pickett and won't be fussed if it means I go down the path of a M11 donut to start with
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Samsturmfels on March 19, 2020, 10:38:58 PM
thoughts on starting Budarick in the fwd line? (fielding taylor aswell (if named)
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: jfitty on March 19, 2020, 10:47:42 PM
Who were you fellas planning to start over Pickett?
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Rusty00 on March 20, 2020, 07:24:18 AM
Who were you fellas planning to start over Pickett?
Rowell and Green
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: LordSneeze on March 20, 2020, 09:37:32 AM
Who were you fellas planning to start over Pickett?
Was hoping Robertson.
Was looking like a good choice when Pickett was on 18 at half time.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: tommy10 on March 20, 2020, 11:28:54 AM
Who were you fellas planning to start over Pickett?
Was hoping Robertson.
Was looking like a good choice when Pickett was on 18 at half time.
Was going to loophole Pickett but ended up starting him. Would have started Budarick if I had Pickett on my bench.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: RaisyDaisy on March 20, 2020, 11:43:51 AM
I'm picking Dev Rob either way

If he isn't named, I use him to loop Pickett's score

If he is named, I dump a fwd rookie, move Budarick to fwd and start Mahony/cheap DPP donut at M11

I prefer going with a donut at M11 so I can loop M8 every week, as opposed to picking Tyler Brown who will likely get dropped sooner rather than later. Even if he does string together a few games makes 100k or so, I'll take the hit as I think I should be able to gain more points by looping M8 each week
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: timtim on March 20, 2020, 11:44:45 AM
Who were you fellas planning to start over Pickett?
Was hoping Robertson.
Was looking like a good choice when Pickett was on 18 at half time.
Was going to loophole Pickett but ended up starting him. Would have started Budarick if I had Pickett on my bench.

Mahony for me. Favorable bye, can loophole him with Budarick. Mahony on ground to get Pickett’s 94 can swing him forward if M11 is needed.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: RoughRed on March 20, 2020, 11:47:43 AM
Who were you fellas planning to start over Pickett?
Was hoping Robertson.
Was looking like a good choice when Pickett was on 18 at half time.
Was going to loophole Pickett but ended up starting him. Would have started Budarick if I had Pickett on my bench.

Mahony for me. Favorable bye, can loophole him with Budarick. Mahony on ground to get Pickett’s 94 can swing him forward if M11 is needed.
What bye ? I thought all byes were gone bye bye!
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: jfitty on March 20, 2020, 11:53:58 AM
How are we ranking the forward rookies lads, in terms of who to field? Depending on who you're picking:

Taylor
Cavarra
King
Sturt
Georgiades
Davis

Assuming most have Budarick in mids and Brander in defence.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: SydneyRox on March 20, 2020, 11:56:27 AM
thoughts on starting Budarick in the fwd line? (fielding taylor aswell (if named)

yup, thats me as well.

Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: jfitty on March 20, 2020, 12:11:22 PM
thoughts on starting Budarick in the fwd line? (fielding taylor aswell (if named)

yup, thats me as well.

I don't mind the look of this, but surely depends on whether Robertson gets named?
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Money Shot on March 20, 2020, 12:15:11 PM
How are we ranking the forward rookies lads, in terms of who to field? Depending on who you're picking:

Taylor
Cavarra
King
Sturt
Georgiades
Davis

Assuming most have Budarick in mids and Brander in defence.

The thing that annoys me is Job Security/Point Scoring are completely different

Job Security
King/Rankine
Davis
Taylor
Georgiades
Cavvara
Sturt
Bedford

Scoring Potential
Taylor
Bedford
Cavvara
Georgiades
Rankine
Davis
King
Sturt

Obviously it’s anyone’s guess but I’m unsure of whether I go for job security or scoring potential

Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: erich1036 on March 20, 2020, 01:20:42 PM
Budarick vs Cavarra?
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: tkringle on March 20, 2020, 01:23:16 PM
Budarick vs Cavarra?

Buda
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: tommy10 on March 20, 2020, 01:41:35 PM
Budarick vs Cavarra?

Buda
+1
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: tommy10 on March 20, 2020, 01:54:48 PM
How are we ranking the forward rookies lads, in terms of who to field? Depending on who you're picking:

Taylor
Cavarra
King
Sturt
Georgiades
Davis

Assuming most have Budarick in mids and Brander in defence.

The thing that annoys me is Job Security/Point Scoring are completely different

Job Security
King/Rankine
Davis
Taylor
Georgiades
Cavvara
Sturt
Bedford

Scoring Potential
Taylor
Bedford
Cavvara
Georgiades
Rankine
Davis
King
Sturt

Obviously it’s anyone’s guess but I’m unsure of whether I go for job security or scoring potential
Summed it up pretty well MS.

IMO I would have Rankine higher than Bedford and Cavarra if fully fit. But, he's not playing rnd 1.
For the playing rookies - seems that Taylor, Davis, Georgiades and King would be my pick.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: _wato on March 20, 2020, 02:03:20 PM
Agree with MS, however do not have Bedford that high at all.

Was the second worst averaging AFL listed player for Casey last year, averaged 51 and was below average in several categories.

Georgiades will probably get Hinkley’d plus Dixon out and he’s a key forward so only want 1 of him and King and King amazing JS.

Taylor a lock. Cavarra close last year before injury, huge internal rating I believe. Locked. Out of the guys left, Sturt will be first to go so no thanks and Davis looks to have solid JS as a mature ager.

So for me

Taylor, Davis on field
Cavarra King on bench.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Money Shot on March 20, 2020, 02:17:23 PM
Agree with MS, however do not have Bedford that high at all.

Was the second worst averaging AFL listed player for Casey last year, averaged 51 and was below average in several categories.

Georgiades will probably get Hinkley’d plus Dixon out and he’s a key forward so only want 1 of him and King and King amazing JS.

Taylor a lock. Cavarra close last year before injury, huge internal rating I believe. Locked. Out of the guys left, Sturt will be first to go so no thanks and Davis looks to have solid JS as a mature ager.

So for me

Taylor, Davis on field
Cavarra King on bench.
I was doing the maths of a very small sample size in the March series.

Luckily I checked this post. Bedford is out. King is in at F8
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Wanderer on March 20, 2020, 02:38:31 PM
Agree with MS, however do not have Bedford that high at all.

Was the second worst averaging AFL listed player for Casey last year, averaged 51 and was below average in several categories.

Georgiades will probably get Hinkley’d plus Dixon out and he’s a key forward so only want 1 of him and King and King amazing JS.

Taylor a lock. Cavarra close last year before injury, huge internal rating I believe. Locked. Out of the guys left, Sturt will be first to go so no thanks and Davis looks to have solid JS as a mature ager.

So for me

Taylor, Davis on field
Cavarra King on bench.

Cavarra or King for last spot?
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: tommy10 on March 20, 2020, 03:43:21 PM
Cavarra v Georgiades for F8?
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: tkringle on March 20, 2020, 04:23:57 PM
Cavarra v Georgiades for F8?

Going Cavarra. Both have questionable JS however I think Georgiades will be straight out for Dixon
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: dylanclements on March 20, 2020, 04:24:45 PM
Picking one of Schultz and Stengle. Any thoughts appreciated!
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Samsturmfels on March 20, 2020, 05:46:53 PM
thoughts on starting Budarick in the fwd line? (fielding taylor aswell (if named)

yup, thats me as well.

I don't mind the look of this, but surely depends on whether Robertson gets named?
yep have had to move buda back in the mids. Now i need to pick one of Davis/Sturt/Geo/Pickett
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Samsturmfels on March 20, 2020, 06:48:58 PM
what rookie is everyone fielding apart from taylor in the forward line? very undecided atm
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: tommy10 on March 20, 2020, 06:54:48 PM
what rookie is everyone fielding apart from taylor in the forward line? very undecided atm
Thinking Davis. Not starting Geo due to his JS, but if you are picking him in your team I would start him vs the Suns.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Bones Bombers on March 20, 2020, 06:57:47 PM
what rookie is everyone fielding apart from taylor in the forward line? very undecided atm
Thinking Davis. Not starting Geo due to his JS, but if you are picking him in your team I would start him vs the Suns.
I moved Brander forward to start.  He was on the bench in the back line and I now have Starcevich and McAsey on the bench back there.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Samsturmfels on March 20, 2020, 07:00:04 PM
what rookie is everyone fielding apart from taylor in the forward line? very undecided atm
Thinking Davis. Not starting Geo due to his JS, but if you are picking him in your team I would start him vs the Suns.
I moved Brander forward to start.
i have Brander in my forward line for the last week but have to move him back due to lack of back rookies
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Bones Bombers on March 20, 2020, 07:02:08 PM
what rookie is everyone fielding apart from taylor in the forward line? very undecided atm
Thinking Davis. Not starting Geo due to his JS, but if you are picking him in your team I would start him vs the Suns.
I moved Brander forward to start.
i have Brander in my forward line for the last week but have to move him back due to lack of back rookies
Sorry, I added to my post. I had the money for McAsey. Gives me flexibility if I need to correction trade.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Samsturmfels on March 21, 2020, 12:20:35 PM
Zac Guthrie v Brander to field.

Undecided who to field. If Guthrie were to score well compared to Brander it would be a huge pod move
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: dmac07 on March 21, 2020, 12:54:05 PM
Zac Guthrie v Brander to field.

Undecided who to field. If Guthrie were to score well compared to Brander it would be a huge pod move
Brander for me
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: dmac07 on March 21, 2020, 12:55:12 PM
Which 2 of, Sturt, King and Georgiades?
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: tommy10 on March 21, 2020, 12:57:03 PM
Which 2 of, Sturt, King and Georgiades?
King and Geo
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: tkringle on March 21, 2020, 01:04:23 PM
Field Georgiades or Taylor at F6?
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Samsturmfels on March 21, 2020, 01:16:46 PM
Field Georgiades or Taylor at F6?
Taylor. Everyone should have him on the field, so if he does bad it wont hurt your team as much.
Title: Re: Who to field thread
Post by: Wanderer on March 21, 2020, 01:20:09 PM
Field Georgiades or Taylor at F6?
Taylor. Everyone should have him on the field, so if he does bad it wont hurt your team as much.
Taylor seems like the one most people are going with and I think he scored in the mid 90's in second Marsh series game.