FanFooty Forum

FanFooty => Supercoach Archive => Archives => 2011 Rate My SC Archive => Topic started by: Nathans Brawlers on August 08, 2011, 06:32:44 PM

Title: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 08, 2011, 06:32:44 PM
Backs : Goddard Fisher Gilbert Deledio Broughton Gibbs and McGrath  <Jacobs Toy Talia> 
Traded in McGrath last week and was meant to get Adcock...

Mids : Pendlebury Swan Priddis Thomson Boyd Montagna <Mzungu Bewick Irons>

Rucks : Cox Mumford <Keeffe Moran>

Forwards : Franklin Pavlich Fyfe N.Roo Goodes Chapman Didak <Syliva Richardson McKernan>

3 trades and $124 000

Think i should bring in Murphy or Grundy for Mzungu for the Gibbs and Chapman bye or Rested players?
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 08, 2011, 06:41:34 PM
Are you going for league or overall?  Top 4 atm?  If so post your opposition's team.

If going for best overall, team looks fine mate.

Would play Mzungu over Didak, I suspect he may get a mid-field tagging role this week again.  So wouldn't want to trade him out.

You should move up seeing you don't have Petrie/Harvey.

Not sure if Sylvia will play, but apparently he had 7-8 disposals in the reserves all game, but he was tagged.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 08, 2011, 06:50:25 PM
I finished 3rd , going for cash leuge .

His team is :

Backs : Fisher Gilbert Deledio Broughton Murphy Lower <Duigan Batchelor Strause>

Mids : Swan Pendlebury Ablett Pavlich Goddard Mitchell <Prestia Mzungu Jacobs>

Rucks : Warnock Luenburger <Lobbe Moran>

Forwards : Goodes ROK Petrie Chappy Franklin Syliva Higgins <Knights Richardson Talia>

Guessing he will use trades this week though
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 08, 2011, 07:03:54 PM
You should have him easily covered.  nail the captaincy.

I'm guessing he has no trades, seeing he has kept higgins?
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 08, 2011, 07:08:22 PM
Its a friendly leuge so i know him personally and about 5 weeks ago he said he had 9 trades left , could be a lie i guess.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 08, 2011, 07:14:58 PM
9 trades lol, my ass!  If i had 9 trades Higgins would have been out the door 3 weeks ago.

umm.. i dunno, your best move is to negate what he has.

His:
Ablett ??  See if he is named.
Mitchell?? should go big against Port Adelaide. 

The rest of your team is pretty similar to his, apart from rucks.

The only people I think might struggle on your team is, Thompson & Montagna. 

I think its better you don't use trades this round.  If you lose you have 2nd chance at the geelong bye, which shouldn't hurt you too much anyway as you only have chappy.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 08, 2011, 07:45:50 PM
Charliesheen : Best helper on fanfooty .
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 08, 2011, 09:01:28 PM
just had another look at his team, who is his 7th defender, soemone is missing?

I finished 3rd , going for cash leuge .

His team is :

Backs : Fisher Gilbert Deledio Broughton Murphy Lower <Duigan Batchelor Strause>

Mids : Swan Pendlebury Ablett Pavlich Goddard Mitchell <Prestia Mzungu Jacobs>

Rucks : Warnock Luenburger <Lobbe Moran>

Forwards : Goodes ROK Petrie Chappy Franklin Syliva Higgins <Knights Richardson Talia>

Guessing he will use trades this week though
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Jay on August 08, 2011, 09:07:37 PM
Charliesheen : Best helper on fanfooty .
+1
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 08, 2011, 09:14:06 PM
Gibbs sorry , doesnt really change much considering i have him aswell.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 08, 2011, 09:30:06 PM
Who do you plan on putting captaincy on?

Still reckon you probably have him, worst case scenario you go to 2nd round.  Better off saving your trades for semis/grand finals.

The bold on which who wins, you vs him

Montagna vs Rob Murphy
McGrath vs Lower

Priddis vs Mitchell (should negate each other, Priddis should do well vs Melbourne)
Boyd vs Ablett (boyd at ES)
S. Thompson vs Higgins

Cox vs Warnock
Mumford vs Leuy

Nroo vs ROK
Fyfe vs Petrie/Knights
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 08, 2011, 10:05:39 PM
Diddnt Knights get injured last week ? and Petrie has the bye , yes?
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 19, 2011, 09:49:05 AM
ok charlie , instead of giving you his who team ill give you the differences from both mine and his team...

Im bottom team :

BACKS:
Adcock Duigan Puopolo - and his one short , gussing he will make at least one trade in the backline
Fisher Broughton Gilbert McGrath

I should win that

MIDS:
Judd Mitchell Heppell Libertore
Ablett Priddis Montagna Boyd

I dont have Ablett but bringing him in this week, should win that aswell.

RUCKS:
Hille Kreuzer
Cox Mummy

I win that

FORWARDS:
Petrie Dangerfeild Krakour
Rioli Syliva Riewoldt

Dont have Rioli yet , also getting him this week.
Dont know if i should start Didak or Syliva this week though ....
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 01:59:40 PM
you should win this easy without trading.

who are you trading out to bring in Ablett & Rioli?
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 19, 2011, 02:05:22 PM
Trading Thompson and Chappy , i thought i would win easy last week as well .
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 02:09:47 PM
Trading Thompson and Chappy , i thought i would win easy last week as well .
howmuch did you lose last week by, and who was your captain?

didn't he have nick lowers 10?

did you start mzungu or didak?
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 19, 2011, 02:16:00 PM
I lost bye 102 , Captain Goodes . Dont have Lower and started Syliva other Didak and Mzungu
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 02:17:42 PM
I lost bye 102 , Captain Goodes . Dont have Lower and started Syliva other Didak and Mzungu

lol well, thats your own fault. you had the stornger team!  he even had Lowers 10 to his score!

should have had Swan/Gaj captain, and should have started Mzungu!


Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 19, 2011, 02:24:50 PM
He made to backline upgrades , Brought Birchall and someone else
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 02:26:57 PM
what do the mids of the other people in your league look like?

I don't mind the ablett trade.  its just impossible to know which will average the least out of...

Thompson
Boyd
Montagna

I think if I were to look at a weakness in your team, it would probably be the back line rather than the forward line.

Mzungu could potentially outscore some of those backs you are pplaying right now.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 19, 2011, 02:35:15 PM
I dont have the cash to do the GAJ trade and a backline trade , I think GAJ is a must
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 02:37:43 PM
yeh Gilbert, Broughton, McGrath (has collingwood & WCE) is kindof looking a bit dodgy.

then you need to do something about Gibbs next round.

so you need to be careful about using 2 trades, for Ablett and Rioli.  Not sure these 2 options are going to offset the amount of points you will lose in the backs.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 02:43:08 PM
I dont have the cash to do the GAJ trade and a backline trade , I think GAJ is a must

Its about team balance....  I'll try explain this better.  You need to factor in the culminative scores of all your players based on your trades.  This is why I think your backline might be a bit dodgy.  For example

TEAM A)
Defender A - averages 60
Midfielder A - averages 110

TOTAL 170

TEAM B)
Defender A - 60
Midfielder B - averages 130

TOTAL 190

TEAM C)
Defender C - averages 100
Midfielder A - averages 110

TOTAL 210
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 19, 2011, 03:05:58 PM
So you think i shouldnt bring in GAJ?
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 03:36:10 PM
I definitely feel you have this won.

Lets say you grab Ablett/Rioli this week, what do you plan to do about Gibbs the week after.  Use your 1 trade to sideways him off?
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 19, 2011, 03:39:55 PM
That was the plan
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 03:45:40 PM
i dunno, I think you are putting all your eggs in 1 basket by doing these trades.  If it works, it could be a master stroke, if it doesn't and someone gets injured you could be in some trouble.

Maybe its better to compromise, and leave 1 trade to cover unforeseen situations, and 1 trade for Gibbs.

This may mean no Rioli or no GAJ.

Up to you mate.  You definitely has this round won though.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 19, 2011, 03:54:06 PM
Im going to trust you and only do the GAJ trade...
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 04:00:44 PM
sylvia/mzungu/didak should do alright this week.

Just don't put captain on GOodes this week.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 19, 2011, 04:03:51 PM
Oh captain Ablett 100% sure . And another thing , who should i start out of the three? im thinking Didak and Mzungu
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 04:07:07 PM
tough one.  im not sure myself tbh.

at least we know his getting a full game.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: roo boys! on August 19, 2011, 04:08:34 PM
Sylvia and Mzungu I reckon.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 19, 2011, 04:15:35 PM
Sylvia and Mzungu I reckon.

didak done too much psychological damage to you?
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: roo boys! on August 19, 2011, 05:08:16 PM
Sylvia and Mzungu I reckon.

didak done too much psychological damage to you?
Yeah, I can hardly even say his name without getting angry now! ;)
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 21, 2011, 09:26:20 PM
Thanks for making me save that trade! will probs need it for pav . just to let you know i got up by 300 +
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 21, 2011, 09:30:43 PM
which one did you get rid of

Boyd
S. Thompson
Montagna

boyd, s.thompson killed it!
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 21, 2011, 09:33:01 PM
Scotty t , im only going for league win so i didnt really matter in the end ... just hope montagna has a good couple of games!

Ill hit you up later in the week ;)
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 21, 2011, 09:34:36 PM
well i can tell you Pav is probably going to be season over.

and broughton is High chance he will miss.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 21, 2011, 09:47:25 PM
My opp has Gibbs , Judd , Pav , and Broughton
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 21, 2011, 09:59:29 PM
nroo could be out too.  and could be sylvia.

gonna be interesting...

trades are gold right now.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 21, 2011, 10:19:04 PM
If i made that rioli trade i would have been history . your a beast!
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 26, 2011, 06:02:46 PM
Start of the week i was going to do the Broughton to Gram and Pav to Cloke .. Now that Broughton is Playing ive got another idea.
How does this sound?
Syliva to $341,000 player.
Pav To Cloke

Pav and Syliva are they only players that wont play the rest of the season (apart from rookies) so i might as well get them out because they will be no use to me
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 26, 2011, 06:09:53 PM
Still don't know if Broughton is late out yet.

Get rid of broughton, his finished, will cost you points playing in back pocket.

just leave Sylvia as a switch for Mzungu.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 26, 2011, 06:24:41 PM
So Broughton to Gram?
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: charliesheen on August 26, 2011, 06:28:39 PM
Broughton > Enright / Birchall / Gram / Gibson /etc
Pavlich > Cloke / Rioli.

something like that.  I would start Mzungu too.
Title: Re: Help me charliesheen :D
Post by: Nathans Brawlers on August 26, 2011, 07:44:47 PM
Ok , Im going with Birchall and Cloke! and i had Mzungu on the ground already with Didak Mid sub