FanFooty Forum

FanFooty => Supercoach Archive => Archives => 2012 Rate My SC Archive => Topic started by: felsty on March 25, 2012, 10:19:01 AM

Title: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on March 25, 2012, 10:19:01 AM
FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD

Hey guys I have decided to post a thread throughout the season on my side and the trades and changes I make each round!
Feel free to comment on my side and give me feedback on trades I should make, players to watch, etc.

Starting Side
B: Goddard, Deledio, H.Shaw, Broughton, Lake, Ellis, Bugg <Mohr, Morris>
M: Ablett, Boyd, Selwood, Coniglio, Shiel, Magner <McDonald, Ledger>
R: Cox, Mumford <Giles, Redden>
F: Franklin, Fyfe, Chapman, Martin, Porplyzia, Smith, Kennedy <Hall, Dickson>

Present Team
B: Goddard, Deledio, H.Shaw, Carrazzo, Lake, Scotland, Waters <Malceski, S.Shaw>
M: Ablett, Boyd, J.Selwood, Dal Santo, Pendlebury, Priddis <Adams, Gibson>
R: Cox, Jacobs < Stephenson, Redden>
F: Franklin, Beams, Chapman, Martin, Pavlich, Dangerfield, Zorko <Sexton, Couch>

Round 1   -   Score: 2100     Average: 2100     Ranking: 43,466     Ablett

Round 2   -   Score: 2085     Average: 2093     Ranking: 60,698     Ablett
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Broughton > Malceski     Dickson > Milera
Round 3   -   Score: 2121     Average: 2102     Ranking: 44,399     Ablett
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Fyfe > Treloar                Ledger > Murphy
Round 4   -   Score: 2106     Average: 2103     Ranking: 29,597     Ablett
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Mumford > Stephenson  Coniglio > Pendlebury
Round 5   -   Score: 1923     Average: 2067     Ranking: 34,204     Pendlebury
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Ablett > Beams              D.Smith > Pavlich
Round 6   -   Score: 2224     Average: 2093     Ranking: 23,325     Murphy
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Milera > T.Adams           A.Kennedy > Horsley
Round 7   -   Score: 2344     Average: 2129     Ranking: 18,401     Pendlebury
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Bugg > Scotland            Shiel > Saad
Round 8   -   Score: 2357     Average: 2158     Ranking: 16,586     Pendlebury
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Murphy > Dangerfield     Magner  > Zorko
Round 9   -   Score: 2233     Average: 2166     Ranking: 10,166     Pendlebury
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Porplyzia > Dal Santo     Morris > Waters
Round 10 -   Score: 2258     Average: 2175     Ranking: 10,909     Pendlebury
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Horsley > Sexton
Round 11 -   Score: 1428     Average: 2107     Ranking: 12,212     Selwood           
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Hall > Priddis                 Mohr > S.Shaw
Round 12 -   Score: 1849     Average: 2086     Ranking: 12,907     Priddis                           
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Treloar > Gibson
Round 13 -   Score: 1570     Average: 2046     Ranking: 9,811       Selwood                   
                                                                                                                    Trades:   McDonald > Ablett
Round 14 -   Score: 2178     Average: 2055     Ranking: 10,064     Ablett
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Giles  > Jacobs
Round 15 -   Score: 2622     Average: 2093     Ranking: 4,358       Selwood

Round 16 -   Score: 2457     Average: 2116     Ranking: 2,773       Ablett

Round 17 -   Score: 2333     Average: 2129     Ranking: 2,266       Ablett

Round 18 -   Score: 2544     Average: 2152     Ranking: 2,018       Pendlebury

Round 19 -   Score: 2576     Average: 2174     Ranking: 1,639       Ablett

Round 20 -   Score: 2384     Average: 2185     Ranking: 1,833       Ablett
                                                                                                                    Trades:   Saad > Couch     Ellis > Carrazzo
Round 21 -   Score: 2379     Average: 2194     Ranking: 1,869        Ablett

Round 22 -   Score: 2510     Average: 2208     Ranking: 1,338        Ablett
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: Locinator on March 25, 2012, 10:34:06 AM
Hey Felsty,

Good Idea I'll watch reguarly

Backs: Same as mine! Great minds think alike ;)
Midfield: Very silimar to mine. Not sure on Ledger though. Will he get games? If his named I'd keep him because he could explode
Rucks: Very Strong. You can definately "Set and Forget" that ruckline
Forwards: Solid. Still not sold on Porpoise but then again I wasn't convinced by Petrie. other rookies are fine.

Overall: 9/10
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: ben_020285 on March 25, 2012, 11:33:14 AM
G'day Felsty. Great structured side with sound player selections. I'm glad to see somebody else is going with the 2 PREMIUM rucks strategy. Can I suggest just one very important thing..

You need more cash in the bank. I made the mistake of having next to no cash in the bank last year and because of it I missed out on some of the gun rookie cash cows and wasn't able to trade out some mid price or premium flops. Let's say that you have a $106,600 rookie who is stinking it up while another rookie priced at $113,200 manages to score 100's in the first 2 rounds. You wouldn't be able to get that rookie in because of your cash issues. I think it's important to set aside 2 trades to be able to either bring in a gun rookie or swap a flop mid pricer or premium. I would advise that 50k should be the minimum amount.

My trade suggestion to make this coin would be Nick Riewoldt for Dustin Martin. Roo had one bad year last year while playing injured and still managed to average 87. He is now fit and the Saints have one of the best draws for the first half of the season. Dustin Martin usually doesn't play well against the top sides and the Tigers have the toughest draw of all for the first half of the season so I reckon he's a great upgrade target for the second half of the season when the Tigers have one of the easiest draws in the competition (behind only Melbourne).

This trade would make you an extra 64k that you can have sitting in the bank to use at your leisure.
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on March 25, 2012, 12:14:23 PM
Its definitely an option.. I know that money is good to have but I don't think it's needed if you are happy with your side.. The option I see is downgrading pfeiffer but the only reason I think I would do that was if Morris or Ellis weren't named.. Overall im pretty happy.. Will be interesting to see how ledger goes but if he does get the vest I have good mid rookies to cover that!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: tor01doc on March 25, 2012, 12:54:52 PM
felsty - NRoo? Surely not.

felsty

 Fantasy coach

« Reply #4 on: March 08, 2012, 12:07:08 PM »

B: solid love the adcock pick
M: love at first sight
R: A. A+ for adding redden
F: rooey will stink it up so thats how you got adcock into your 5th defender! :O

 
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: mumfster on March 25, 2012, 01:00:43 PM
Hey Felsty!

Cant be bothered writing a big speech. However i would like to point out that you only have 3 premium mids....! Mids make up a good portion of your score, and you can basically always count on well over 100+ from these players. i know your banking on Mummy & Cox to make up for it, but down the line i think it may cost you.

Also i do worry about the GWS bye with the 8 players that you have from their team? how will you cover all those players? You might have upgraded some by then, but its a lot of trades to be using to avoid having bulk players on  a bye.

We will see... 
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on March 25, 2012, 01:02:09 PM
I don't think I ever had Rooey in my team.. The guy is past his prime! :S
He has been slowly declining the past couple of years and I honestly can't imagine him scoring over 90 tops!
90avg doesn't define a keeper to me :P
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on March 25, 2012, 01:09:57 PM
Cheers for the concern! I will have traded in a lot of cows by then but I also think a lot of us are losing sight of our goals by taking a short sighted view on preparing for the byes. The way I see it I'm trying to get a well structured team in I can count on and worry about the byes when I come to it. But like I said I wouldn't just trade out a gws rookie when it is coming up to bye time if he still has a lot of fattening up to do..
In the mids I felt like a lot of solid rookies are from there and I have selected the best on offer. Another reason is the amount of fwd/mid rookies that can fit in there too! Boyd and Ablett are prolific scorers and Selwood is way underpriced and can score heavily himself. Plus you're right about my rucks.. They should be able to cover 4mid 1ruck premiums easily enough
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on March 25, 2012, 08:46:31 PM
im having a few doubts on broughtons role in the fremantle team once players come back in (Mundy, Barlow, etc.)
follow this link, i would love to hear your opinion on the player i have earmarked to take his place.. http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,53076.0.html
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - HELP NEEDED! follow the link
Post by: mpollock on March 25, 2012, 10:30:38 PM
@ben_020285

I agree with the money in the bank but 50k is excessive ... I would suggest more like 15k to avoid the rookie problem you mentioned (that i got caught with one year as well).  50k is not utilizing all your cash which is a big mistake.

Also, NRoo ... has shown ABSOLUTELY nothing last year as so far this year in the NAB.  I know he was an absolute GUN in the past and may be again ... but there is zero justification for picking him up front this year.  If him or J.Brown etc come good then jump on later i reckon.

Great team feltsy ... love the lock and forget ... had cox/mummy most of the pre-season but changed to have 3 rookies with mummy at the last minutes ... Giles looked good so worth it so far (also have Hale as a backup plan in the forward line).
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - HELP NEEDED! follow the link
Post by: felsty on March 26, 2012, 07:04:21 AM
Yeah money is a bit of a worry but I don't feel like I'm going to miss out on much and if I have I'm not too worried because I'm very happy with the rookies I have in my side
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: mpollock on March 26, 2012, 02:20:18 PM
At the moment you have Kennedy, McDonald and Bugg who were the standout rookies so far along with Giles of course.
I am sure someone like Hall for example who you don't have will kill it .. not such a big deal as he is ony $106k price bracket but if Spurr gets promoted and kills it that would really suck not having the cash to jump on without a mid/gun downgrade.

Like always ... risk v reward ... good luck ... strong team mate!!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on March 26, 2012, 03:19:44 PM
I just hope coniglio fires up for the next round. Shiel I can excuse but I paid good money for Cogs!!  >:(
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on March 27, 2012, 09:37:44 AM
Been tinkering around with a 3 rookie ruck
downgrading cox and upgrading lake/porpoise but also looking at midprice mid options

follow the link and let me know what you think! - http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,53213.msg694716.html#new
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - HELP NEEDED! follow the link
Post by: tor01doc on March 27, 2012, 10:38:40 AM
WCE have the one of the easiest draws to start.

Cox will not drop a lot, especially if NicNat is doubtful.

Save yourself a trade and keep Cox.
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on March 27, 2012, 11:51:26 PM
I have made a few changes.. Decided that with Smith and Kennedy looking alright and some options for forward rookies I downgrade Porps to Jamie Cripps - as a saints supporter I see him getting a very good run, paying the little extra because I don't think he will be vested.. Another option to go for is Pfeiffer.
With the money I upgrade Broughton to Scotland, could be a bad idea as he will probably drop in price but 100+ average backmen are hard to come bye (sorry about the pun!) so I won't have to worry about trading him in later!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - please comment
Post by: tor01doc on March 28, 2012, 03:38:19 PM
Hey feisty

Do you think Scotland will outscore Broughton by $70800?

I think no.

Could you have kept Porps and get Cripps? I think they'll do better with Broughton than Scotland and 2 rookies.

Cheers big ears.
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - please comment
Post by: felsty on March 28, 2012, 03:42:21 PM
I HATE BROUGHTON!!  >:(
He seriously does my head in.. I would almost rather heppell!!
If I had to get rid of Broughton who would you trade him too??
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - please comment
Post by: tor01doc on March 28, 2012, 03:59:22 PM
Adcock / Hanley / Hurn??

Birchall / Suckling / Newman?

Hurn is gaining momentum.
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - please comment
Post by: felsty on March 28, 2012, 04:04:21 PM
Backline is horrible this year because of the byes.. How good would it be just to roll out Goddard, Deledio, Scotland, Bock in your backs :(
I'm tempted to grab Scotland along with my locks because they are the only guys that I trust  :-\
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - please comment
Post by: tor01doc on March 28, 2012, 04:16:47 PM
Now you're heading towards my tank round 13 plan.

Only problem is % and overall.

Overall not my aim so %.

Score 34 points for the round and watch your percentage plummet and cost you a double chance.

I'm backing myself to win that round in some leagues as well as 11 and 12.

Don't bye too many donuts! PS You're so punny feisty!

Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - please comment
Post by: felsty on March 29, 2012, 12:18:31 PM
are there any changes people think i should make leading up to the lockout?
if you havent seen the side check the top of the first page!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - please comment
Post by: mumfster on March 29, 2012, 01:48:50 PM
Keep big Cox! Cox and mummy make a good pair
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - please comment
Post by: felsty on March 29, 2012, 02:25:33 PM
Keep big Cox! Cox and mummy make a good pair
that is just because its what youre lacking! lol
i find myself trying to justify that this is a good side but for some reason im just not happy.. maybe im just a perfectionist :P
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread - HELP NEEDED, follow the link
Post by: felsty on March 30, 2012, 10:21:27 AM
my very last poll before final round 1 lockout!
follow the link and let me know what you think..
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,53806.0.html
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: Ringo on March 30, 2012, 02:30:31 PM
Felsty - Do not beat yourself up over it.  Most teams dependent on structure will have a small weakness in one line due to Salary Cap pressures.  Teams will mostly have 13/14 prems so dependent on how this is structured a slight weakness will always be there. Trick is to balance by selecting right rookies and I have not been very succesful this round at all.
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on March 30, 2012, 03:22:52 PM
cheers ringo,
think ill stick with Lake and Porps. even if they dont come off they will rise a bit in cash
Heppell and Cloke looked good but it really left my backline vulnerable..
and it is a huge shame about morris. i wasnt expecting a whole heap but a 50 would have been good.. ellis was a let down as well
im sure the rest of the rookies cant be too bad.. we cant go wrong with magner, ledger, etc. ;)
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 01, 2012, 07:42:26 PM
ROUND 1   -   Score: 2100   Ranking: 43,466

Winners: Buddy and Captain GAJ with support from Selwood, Goddard, Boyd and Cox and a beauty by Magner
Sinners: Lake, starting Coniglio and Shiel, and the role of Greg Broughton
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: tor01doc on April 01, 2012, 08:11:12 PM
Smashed that with a 2102!  :P
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 01, 2012, 09:01:58 PM
very solid doctor! was a terrible round i cant believe i pulled that out after some of the players i had.. broughton, lake :P god i wanna trade those two already!!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: tor01doc on April 01, 2012, 09:44:16 PM
Jury's out on Broughton.

Lake - fire sale after round 2 for ? Hargrave? - or even Clarke - or a 'bubble boy' rookie about to jump through the roof.

Porps!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 02, 2012, 09:46:25 AM
porps i can deal with.. nothing wrong with his score. he had a bad day and still pulled a what 74? not bad imo - i wasnt expecting much more..
Thinking of getting Clay Smith in for Cogs and saving the money but i wanna do it this week because i want round 2 to see if broughtons role changes and if lake can do any better.. at least he scored 30 in the first round and not the 3rd round!
ps. i was thinking dempsey for lake? ;)
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: Locinator on April 02, 2012, 06:57:18 PM
Referring to your team on final team in the first post

Backs: Solid
Midfield: Great. Keep Coniglio he'll average 80+ for the season. Trust me!
Rucks: Solid
Forwards:Solid

Very solid! Picked the right rookies. Have great premiums.

Overall: 9.5/10
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: Locinator on April 02, 2012, 07:29:21 PM
Also felsty keep Lake, Coniglio, Broughton and Shiel.

I think everyones turned off by them after JUST ONE PERFORMANCE

Broughton was on track for a century after 20 something in the first quarter. Then he started the second great then Lyon was a muppet and forced him into a lockdown role. Even if he doesn't do well this week and people trade him he'll be a gun.

Conglio will be better than David Swallow was last year. And if you remember it took Swallow a while to take off and by the end of the year he was averaging 80

Sheil should have been a top 3 pick if he wasn't prelisted

Lake will be fine. He was playing a guy 3 inches taller than him. No wonder he didn't play well.






Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: tor01doc on April 02, 2012, 10:23:14 PM
Re Lake...Gibson plays on a guy 3 inches taller than him (and the rest) week in week out.

Take the plunge - out of the Lake!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 02, 2012, 11:15:37 PM
Mm will be interesting.. Who do you guys think will be better out of cogs or smith in the long run? First upgrade will be mids so its not like I'll be trading down to smith and using the money elsewhere but if smith pulls out another 80+ game I'll def have to consider him. With Broughton and Lake I'm hoping one of them fires enough this week for me to want to keep them
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: Locinator on April 03, 2012, 10:43:10 AM
Cogs!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: tor01doc on April 03, 2012, 11:34:45 AM
If Smith plays another blinder then go for him purely for the cash short term.
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 03, 2012, 11:53:35 AM
Its a bit sad when all I see when I look at Smith, Kennedy, Magner are big fat dollar signs lol if Smith kills it again will surely jump a good 50-70k for sure!!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: mumfster on April 03, 2012, 08:23:44 PM
Hey Felsty,

I think you should get rid of Lake. He didnt even look like scoring well at any point against WCE. He didnt make any forward runs, or contested marks. He tried to get cheap kicks in the backline but eagles went 50/50 most of the time. Possible trade to Dempsey from bombers who looks lively
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 04, 2012, 08:16:42 AM
Thinking waiting til next week mumf! Tht way I can see how lake goes and who would be best to trade him for..
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: tor01doc on April 04, 2012, 12:29:58 PM
We all need patients.
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 04, 2012, 03:43:33 PM
We all need patients.
especially the doctor ;)
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 06, 2012, 09:19:22 PM
not trading before round 2
havent really seen enough of the team to start making calls but atm the blokes who i am having a good look at in my team are brian lake and greg broughton. hopefully these two show a bit more than there round 1 results, something that i think they can both rectify this weekend against the crows and swans respectfully!

clay smith is also one i am looking at getting in, maybe at the expense of coniglio and saving the money as im pretty happy with the rest of the rookies. morris and dickson didnt show much but treloar and zorko should be coming in soon so im not too worried
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: tor01doc on April 06, 2012, 09:56:49 PM
felst-meister

Get Adcock! No seriously, hang on to Broughton for a bit longer.

You'll spew if he fires, which he will (at some stage).

No trades is the best policy at the moment.

Smith is on the radar but worries aplenty re vestimenty.

Pity you didn't get Murphy! McD would have been a great Captain this week for you.

Hope your mate Ledger gets going this week.

Good luck.
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 06, 2012, 10:09:22 PM
Yeah would have been nice but Ablett will beat Murphy's anyway so it doesn't really matter ;)
Ledger should smash it mate.. been waiting for this day for a loooooong time!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 06, 2012, 10:29:03 PM
ROUND 2 TEAM

No trades
B: Ellis (bench, E), Mohr (field)
M: Shiel (bench, E) Ledger (field)
R: no change
F: no change, Hall (E)

Ablett (C), Goddard (VC)
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 10, 2012, 11:46:57 AM
ROUND 2   -   Score: 2085   Ranking: 60,698

Winners: Deledio and Goddard beefed up the backs, Ablett captain again, Selwood, Chappy and a big shout out to my two mid pricers - Lake and Porplyzia both magnificent!
Sinners: once again Gregory Broughton. Will be looking to dispose of him this week!
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: GoldDigger on April 10, 2012, 11:54:31 AM
You don't think losing Ledger and Hall is more important than hate for Greg?
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: felsty on April 10, 2012, 04:02:58 PM
not in the slightest.. so many quality forward rookies to come in, treloar, zorko, etc. that even if i did trade out hall or dickson i would probably jump on these blokes anyway in a couple of rounds time.. ill ride them out and downgrade to them later once they are on the bubble..
as with ledger i see massive upside to his game so long as he isnt the sub. looked in great touch last quarter this week which is hopefully a platform for him to kick start his season.. not going to waste trades on rookies that are already playing..

trying to improve my overall position on last season (24,000) and i have started horribly so definitely need a shake up and coniglio and broughton are the two i am looking at getting rid of to improve my on field performance

if dickson or hall or another rookie arent named ill trade them out but ill probably still do the broughton downgrade, leaving coniglio as he will still rise somewhat

at the moment looking at doing..

Broughton > Marty Clarke
Coniglio > Josh P. Kennedy


what do people think of these possible trades before price changes?
Title: Re: Felstys 2012 SC Team Thread
Post by: GoldDigger on April 10, 2012, 04:06:04 PM
I have those two players, and don't plan to trade them. I too am trying to improve on my overall. It's a tad better than yours ...

8,767
Title: Re: What do people think of these changes??
Post by: felsty on April 11, 2012, 05:13:41 PM
looking at either of these trades for the week, what do you think?

Option 1
Broughton > Dempsey

Option 2
Broughton > Marty Clarke, Coniglio > Josh Kennedy

Option 3
Broughton > Smedts, Coniglio > Scott Thompson
Title: Re: What do people think of these changes??
Post by: mumfster on April 11, 2012, 06:14:00 PM
Option 2 or 3 my Super Saiyan lookalike friend
Title: Re: What do people think of these changes??
Post by: felsty on April 11, 2012, 06:26:10 PM
mumfster, currently have broughton > dempsey, dickson > milera
will probably keep it!
Title: Re: What do people think of these changes??
Post by: GoldDigger on April 11, 2012, 09:40:42 PM
looks good, go for it!
Title: Re: What do people think of these changes??
Post by: felsty on April 12, 2012, 09:56:51 PM
Trades before Round 3 are Broughton > Malceski and Dickson > Milera, hopefully it pays off this week!

In hindsight broughton trade looks useless but his rollercoaster output is what i traded him out for and malceski will hopefully give me some consistency, 80 points while being tagged for the game is a nice start!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: felsty on April 15, 2012, 07:41:39 PM
Round 3 Results   -   Score: 2121

Winners: Shaw, Mumford and Boyd lifted their games, Selwood was a shining light and solid scores from Dids and Goddard in defence as well as Big Cox, but the biggest winner was captain Ablett!

Sinners: Milera, Chapman and Fyfe really hurt my scoring however all my other rookies were serviceable, particularly my GWS players!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: felsty on April 20, 2012, 02:00:08 PM
looking at trading shaw > clarke and coniglio > murphy

my scores have been down on last year and think i need another premium mid to get back up the rankings

if fyfe is pulled out or is the sub for tonight chances are i will change my trades to this

fyfe > treloar and ledger > murphy

atm im still in two minds as to what to do.. have played with the idea of leaving it but my scoring for this week will be pretty average
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: charliesheen on April 20, 2012, 02:01:58 PM
can post whole team again?   ???
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: felsty on April 20, 2012, 02:12:48 PM
can post whole team again?   ???

sorry probably a good idea!

B: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Malceski, Lake, Bugg, Morris <Ellis, Mohr>
M: Ablett, Boyd, J.Selwood, Coniglio, Magner, Shiel <McDonald, Ledger>
R: Cox, Mumford <Giles, Redden>
F: Franklin, Fyfe, Chapman, Martin, Porplyzia, Kennedy, D.Smith <Milera, Hall>

$130k remaining

what do you think?
Shaw, Coniglio > Clarke, M.Murphy or Fyfe, Ledger > Treloar, M.Murphy
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: charliesheen on April 20, 2012, 02:40:10 PM
Would keep Coniglio.  Not against those trades, very aggressive.  I think Ellis named on extended bench so don't know what that is going to mean.  Might be risky not having emergency.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: felsty on April 20, 2012, 03:49:02 PM
wanted to improve on my 20,000 ranking and at 46,000 i need to make a move now.. thinking getting murphy in for a player who isnt playing the next two games and clarke who will more than likely outscore coniglio based on what i have seen
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: Locinator on April 20, 2012, 04:08:39 PM

sorry probably a good idea!

B: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Malceski, Lake, Bugg, Morris <Ellis, Mohr>
M: Ablett, Boyd, J.Selwood, Coniglio, Magner, Shiel <McDonald, Ledger>
R: Cox, Mumford <Giles, Redden>
F: Franklin, Fyfe, Chapman, Martin, Porplyzia, Kennedy, D.Smith <Milera, Hall>

$130k remaining

what do you think?
Shaw, Coniglio > Clarke, M.Murphy or Fyfe, Ledger > Treloar, M.Murphy

Wait a couple weeks for murphy at least. Sure he'll go up 50-75k but cogs would have gone up 100-(potetially)150k

And I'm keeping Shaw as well. I can see the arguement of gettig clarke but I already have him. And if your really not impressed by cogs you can downgrade to Trealoar next week or Lachie Neale in 2 weeks. Also Ledger should come back to. But there again if he isn't named in the next couple of weeks pick up Trealoar, Neale or Potentially Zorko. And why can't you if Fyfe goes down this week trade to the same targets or Dell'Olio or Tom Couch in the next couple of weeks. Yes he play lose 50k but if he gets a 200 this week (Incredibly unlikely) and averages 120+ for the rest of the season you will be spewing.

Keep them all. No need to say thank you when you play your grand final and you won because you traded a resting player
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: felsty on April 21, 2012, 12:36:04 PM
Ended up trading Fyfe out for Treloar a week earlier than I would have liked and then upgraded Ledger to Marc Murphy. A pretty good trade if you ask me. This way I still keep Coniglio making me money and Fyfe looks to be quite shot
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: felsty on April 22, 2012, 12:42:43 PM
Need Chapman, Martin, Morris, Malceski and Boyd to make 400 today to win all my leagues.. What do you think, can I do it? Think I'll need close to 150 from Boyd to be a good chance.. Two hundreds straight up from Martin and Chapman would be nice!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD
Post by: felsty on April 22, 2012, 09:24:09 PM
Score for Round 4 was 2106 which I'm pretty happy with considering the carnage! My traded in players of Murphy and Treloar played well!

Winners: Murphy, Giles, Chapman, Selwood, Malceski, GAJ and Porplyzia above average!
Sinners: Devon Smith and Adam Kennedy failed to reach their lofty heights and Milera and Magner were a little down however the tiger rookies in Ellis and Morris made up for them!

Hopefully don't need to make any trades next week as I'm sitting pretty with premiums to come back - heater, lakes and the big sausage eater!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on April 24, 2012, 10:39:56 AM
my team as it currently stands is..

B: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Malceski, Lake, Bugg, Eliis <Morris, Mohr>
M: Ablett, Murphy, J.Selwood, Boyd, Coniglio, Shiel <J.McDonald, Magner>
R: Cox, Mumford <Giles, Redden>
F: Franklin, Chapman, Martin, Porplyzia, Kennedy, Milera, Treloar <Smith, Hall>

I'm thinking of not using any trades this week, however I do have a few concerns in bold

Wanted to keep Mumford and Shaw as I cant see them being out for too much longer, and well Ablett is Ablett, I could never trade him out of my team.. my rookies are excellent, making me a lot of dough and I have 20 trades left for the season

Do you think there is any other parts of my team that needs fixing?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: Ringo on April 24, 2012, 11:09:02 AM
Have you got much cash available to you.  If not I would consider trading Mumford I know they say it was effect of infection from injection but having injections for back problems worries me!! Just personal as over the years we have seen the effect of back injuries.  From left field for you as you also have Giles I would consider Mumford to Maric for the extra cash.  Maric has performed reasonably well so far this year and at $382k may be be good value.

However in saying this you really do not to trade at all. idf satisfied with Mumford
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on April 24, 2012, 01:34:42 PM
thanks ringo i will leave it for now... was looking right into mumford > stephenson, coniglio > pendlebury but i decided i would wait another week or two just to see if i can get the money out of my rookies..

do you think this would be a better idea? i think i would rather mummy than cox tbh.. no.1 ruck at his club, proven big scorer etc.. if i wait a week and mummy is named and plays well i would consider trading cox next week for pendles
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: Ringo on April 24, 2012, 01:44:35 PM
Not a bad idea but who to get for Cox. I know it is possibly sideways but will make some cash is Cox to Nic Nat.  Seems to be the one at eagles at the moment. Would even be tempted to do the trade this week as Cox has a B/e of 153 whereas Nic Nat is 111.  just a thought for you to consider especially if Mumford plays.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on April 24, 2012, 01:58:54 PM
realistically, if i didnt touch my premiums and only got pendlebury in by downgrading and upgrading my rookies how long do you think it would take for me to get him? i think it will take too long and pendleburys price might have risen by then making it a bit harder for me.. giles is good enough to be my number 2 ruck atm but i just cant get rid of mumford with cox playing like he is can i?
deicisons decisions
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: Ringo on April 24, 2012, 02:15:41 PM
Just sit and ride it out till Pendleberrys Price bottoms out His B/e against Dons is 188 for starters then he plays Bulldogs, Brisbane and Geelong. So I can see 2 weeks before he really bottoms out and then you can work something out.  I am in the same boat as I need Murphy and Pendles to complete my mids so am watching both closely to see when to get in if able.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: charliesheen on April 24, 2012, 02:16:41 PM
Yeah tough one.  Not sure I can justify going 3RR with only 20 trades.  Think your just going to cop it on the chin with Giles smashing out decent scores.

Sit on trades for now.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on April 24, 2012, 02:22:09 PM
Yeah tough one.  Not sure I can justify going 3RR with only 20 trades.  Think your just going to cop it on the chin with Giles smashing out decent scores.

Sit on trades for now.

more than happy to do so ;) thanks for the input guys! really helped
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on April 26, 2012, 05:21:45 PM
Really annoyed at myself but im probably just unlucky.. Had a lot of mucking around with my structure up until this round. Decided that mummy and cox in tandem would be as good as any gun midfielder but got that wrong with nicnats emergence and mummys bad back.. Also went 3 premium mids to capitalize on the great rookies available however was a bad decision as I wanted to increase my overall ranking on last year (Going horribly at the moment) picked players from Fwds and Backs who were in strong form but are now quite up and down (chapman, dusty, broughts) I suppose that is to be expected though. Now I have one less forward (fyfe) and ruck premium (mummy) for two extra mid premiums (Murphy and Pendles). Feel like I have wasted my trades a little but didn't want to be behind the 8 ball anymore than I already was... Hope it pays off with some big increases on my overall ranking
WONT MAKE THE SAME MISTAKES AGAIN!

on a side note i traded out mummy this week for pendles and thought it would be a bad thing but with mummys new injury news i may have been a masterstroke :D
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on April 29, 2012, 08:47:05 PM
Round 5 - Score: 1923

Winners: Murphy, Boyd, Giles, Jelwood, Pendles, Buggy, Martin and Dids.. a few of these players really stepped up!
Sinners: Devon being the sub and the lack of Porpoise sundary afternoon didnt help, goddard and malceski in the backline really hurt as well

Current Side

B: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Malceski, Lake, Bugg, Morris <Mohr, Ellis>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Murphy, Selwood, Boyd, McDonald <Shiel, Magner>
R: Cox, Giles <Redden, Stephenson>
F: Franklin, Chapman, Martin, Porplyzia, Milera, Kennedy, Smith <Hall, Treloar>
$114,400 in the salary cap!

not too sure what to look at this week but maybe an upgrade for porps depending on how his injury is? question mark over malceski but with shaw coming back i will just leave him.. maybe downgrading smith could work but im not really sure who to.. looking at horsely for next week but may have to get him in this week if i cant find a premium replacement for porps
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 01, 2012, 01:46:24 PM
have to see what the news is on porplyzias injury but im thinking of holding him as he has a lot more money to make.. same with devon smith!
i also dont have the trades at the moment to warrant  me doing such quick trades..
if porp is out he will be traded up to goodes at the next possible chance
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: charliesheen on May 01, 2012, 02:33:26 PM
You've weakened your forward line too much.  Would definitely consider upgrading it.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 01, 2012, 08:11:43 PM
Yeah very true cs.. It's my first area for upgrade.. Prob look at goodes, Stevie j, roughie as a roughie!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: Ringo on May 01, 2012, 08:33:56 PM
Roughy may be ok for you as he will give you options for rucks in byes.  Could be useful if Reddan and Stephenson do not get games soon. Downgrade to Pattinson and use how we used Joel Tippett/Petrie last year.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: charliesheen on May 02, 2012, 03:39:14 PM
I would definitely consider Pfieffer this week based on who is named.  Horsley next week, will allow you to grab another premium forward.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 02, 2012, 03:54:53 PM
with porps named and at least another good two weeks of money to be made im going to keep him.. probably keep devon smith too although he may be the stepping stone needed to get goodes. horsely is a must next week if he pulls out numbers like that again and is playing on the bubble..

all in all no trades this week and looking at magner/shiel > horse and devon > goodes next week

what do you guys think?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 04, 2012, 02:05:18 PM
really sounds like abletts injury is pretty bad.. few rumours flying around that he didnt train today...

atm i have Ablett, Devon Smith out -> Goodes and Beams in..

good? may reverse this after more ablett news
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 04, 2012, 05:04:59 PM
had a change of heart

Ablett > Pavlich
Hall > Beams

plan to get ablett back... will just do rookie upgrades/downgrades as i go and when ablett is coming in i will most likely have to use the money made by porps and switch pavlich into the forwards for smith.. to do this need ablett to at least not come back for the next 2 rounds including this one. judging by the word on the street this is more than likely! Save 80k in picking pav over goodes which should also help get Ablett, plus goodes can still get a tad cheaper

goodes will also come down in price so i can pick him up then
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 07, 2012, 06:58:15 AM
Round 6 Score - 2224

Well looks like the gamble for trading out Ablett worked in the short term. Beams looks to have taken Balls position in the midfield getting a lot of tackles and clearances on Friday night! Pavlich is an out an out star and I think the longer he plays under Ross's game plan the better he will become!

Winners - the two mentioned above as well as the dogs and pies boys for setting me up Friday night, Deledio and Goddard bouncing back, Big Cox finally without NicNat, Franklin getting a hold on my beloved Saints :( and Chappy showin his true colors at home!

Sinners - Boyd and Selwood nowhere near there best!

This week looking at the downgrading of Milera and Kennedy depending on their respective BEs.. Looking at definitely getting Horsley in and possibly Patch Adams!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 09, 2012, 03:51:31 PM
this weeks trades looking at being Kennedy > Horsley through Beams DPP and Milera > Adams

trading plan goes along the lines of getting Ablett in next week by downgrading a backmen, probably Morris, and upgrading Magner to him. After that a few upgrades in the backline are a must if there are rookies to downgrade to.. looking at Wilkes, Docherty, Spurr, Brennan.. not a lot happening here though.. im hoping that Shiel will be ripe when Zorko is on the bubble giving me a much needed DPP in the mids.. hopefully before bye time!

What does everyone think?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: Locinator on May 09, 2012, 05:29:55 PM
Great trades Felst  ;)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 09, 2012, 05:57:20 PM
Great trades Felst  ;)

even if it leaves me with 14 trades left? :S
trying to go hard early this year as i have been a bit too conservative in the past..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 11, 2012, 06:51:39 AM
Well in hindsight I probably shouldn't have traded ablett! Oh well I get a week to look at him and if he doesn't make his BE I might leave it for a couple of weeks til his price drops.. Still getting on the Horsley & Adams Express at the expense of Kennedy and Milera!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 14, 2012, 07:36:53 AM
2158 with murphy and goddard to come! should be a good week, but so should everyone else
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: Ringo on May 14, 2012, 09:03:34 PM
Looks like we all made a mistake in trading Milera out.  Sound reasons to do it as nearly at his ceiling then he produces this so far. (Don't care if I put the mockers on him as he was traded).
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 14, 2012, 11:12:25 PM
Precisely the reason I don't want to get rid of Ellis yet.. Round 13 is ages away!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: GoldDigger on May 14, 2012, 11:19:09 PM
Nice hold - but gees I had Ellis on field - that hurts!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 15, 2012, 07:10:34 AM
Round 7 Score - 2344

Winners: Dids, To be Shaw, God and the Premium Brian Lake! Boyd and Selwood always working hard. Huge output from Giles/Cox combo made up for the midfield, and finally my functioning forward line at last!

Sinners: Pendles and Murphy having down days, Martin with the start that he had

All in all a pretty good week! Jumped 5000 ranking places. Doing a lot of early trades and it is working out nicely! Getting Ablett this week and then an upgrade to Scotland in the backs and I'll save them
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 15, 2012, 10:08:40 AM
Bugg > Smedts
Shiel > Ablett

Bugg and Shiel surely have to get a rest soon and dont seem to have the same scoring capabilities they once had. this as well as there 82 and 52 BEs i think it is time for them to go..
Smedts to me is the logical choice, great JS and can score alright for a bench player, probably stay on my pine all year
Ablett's price wont go up or down much more but im not sure whether to get him this week or hold for one more week to get shiels price rise.. think the points will outweigh the profit gain..

Thoughts?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 16, 2012, 05:53:25 PM
thanks for the feedback guys  :P

had a change fo heart and am now thinking of going

Bugg & Ellis > Smedts & Scotland

as opposed to the mid upgrade to ablett! i think ill wait another week for that for ablett to go down and shiel and magner go up!

thoughts this time round?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 18, 2012, 05:13:01 PM
Trades!

Shiel > Saad
Bugg > Scotland

Still leaves me with easily enough moolah to get Ablett and Zorko next week for Magner and Porps! Then I'm all set for byes.. Plan on bringing in Scotty T to finish off my mids after round 11 then an Enright/Heppell and Sidebottom in after there round 12 bye. Then my team is finished! Only 4 trades though for the rest of the season so barring any injury I should be alright :)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - thoughts appreciated!
Post by: felsty on May 20, 2012, 11:50:50 PM
Round 8 Score - 2357

Not a bad score considering I had Pav (48) and Murphy (38) in my team, otherwise I would be looking at a monster score!

Probably a bit silly with my trades considering Spurr's output against Saad but the difference is I can now upgrade Porplyzia who has hit his BE to Ablett using the mpp :D could be a good thing considering Murphys lay off :S
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Operation Get Back Gary!
Post by: felsty on May 21, 2012, 12:02:09 PM
Really wanting to get Zorko into my side and need to get Ablett as I think he is going to start getting back into the swing of things..

Porplyzia > Zorko
Magner > Ablett

Good? Bad? Ugly? Was trying to get rid of Hall for Zorko and still grab Ablett but it's almost impossible :( only way I can do it is if I don't pick Ablett and he nevers comes back into the side.. What does everyone think? Team is as follows..

B: Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, Shaw, Lake, Malceski, Mohr <Ellis, Morris>
M: Pendlebury, Selwood, Boyd, Murphy, McDonald, Horsley <Magner, Adams>
R: Cox, Giles <Redden, Stephenson>
F: Franklin, Chapman, Beams, Martin, Porplyzia, Treloar <Saad, Hall>
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Operation Get Back Gary!
Post by: Ringo on May 21, 2012, 12:35:59 PM
I'm seriously considering cashing in Mac for Zorko. Know he has been out for 2 weeks and low B/e but even if Mac is in and out with resting I think Zorko over the next 6 weeks will offer better JS and value. Just my opinion though.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Operation Get Back Gary!
Post by: felsty on May 21, 2012, 05:34:40 PM
I'm seriously considering cashing in Mac for Zorko. Know he has been out for 2 weeks and low B/e but even if Mac is in and out with resting I think Zorko over the next 6 weeks will offer better JS and value. Just my opinion though.

What are your thoughts on Murphy Ringo? Have been trading hard to get a set team after a terrible first few weeks and only have 12 left, I would be keeping him if it wasn't for the byes and his big fat zero taking up space on my bench.. It's a tough one
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Operation Get Back Gary!
Post by: Ringo on May 21, 2012, 06:55:47 PM
I'd wait for diagnosis before making decision.  If longer than 3/4 weeks I would pull the trigger and get Ablett in.
As an alternate can you afford Porps to Sidey. Using Dpp play Sidey in the mids till Murph comes back. Only problem would need 2 of Mac Horse and Adams/Zorko (depending on which DPP) to play each week.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Operation Get Back Gary!
Post by: felsty on May 22, 2012, 09:52:00 AM
I'd wait for diagnosis before making decision.  If longer than 3/4 weeks I would pull the trigger and get Ablett in.
As an alternate can you afford Porps to Sidey. Using Dpp play Sidey in the mids till Murph comes back. Only problem would need 2 of Mac Horse and Adams/Zorko (depending on which DPP) to play each week.

Not possible if I want to get Ablett in, however I will be making that exact trade next week.. Porplyzia > Danger or Sidey, probably Danger if he doesn't go up too much in price
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Operation Get Back Gary!
Post by: felsty on May 22, 2012, 10:01:50 AM
REVELATION!

Murphy > Dangerfield, Magner > Zorko

Then next week I'll have easily enough money to upgrade Porplyzia to Ablett in one hit! Also almost finishes off my forward line with Danger.. Means my premiums on each line will read 6/4/2/6 note that I am calling Giles a premium/keeper if he keeps scoring the way he is!

Will definitely save my last mid spot for Murphy by upgrading/downgrading Jmac and Horse and will hopefully organize Scotty T and Waters to come into my side after there round 11 byes
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Operation Get Back Gary!
Post by: felsty on May 25, 2012, 07:05:09 AM
With the naming of the teams I will be looking at doing the trade above ^^
Next week plan is to upgrade Porps to GAJ with the 420k in my bank and a possible downgrade Morris > Darley, depending on Darleys JS.

this should give me enough trades to bring in Waters and Scotty T after there round 11 bye, then all I have to do is trade in Murphy again when his price comes crashing down and I'll have a strong team with either Zorko/Treloar filling f7 and Cox/Giles ruck combo.. What does everyone think?

Round 9          Murphy > Dangerfield, Magner > Zorko
Round 10        Porplyzia > Ablett, Rookie downgrade..
Round 11        -
Round 12        Morris/Mohr > Waters, Adams > Thompson/Rockcliff                         Round 11 is my easiest week. 12/13 harder
Round 13         -

B: Lake, Mohr - Shaw, Malceski  - Goddard, Scotland, Deledio, Ellis - Waters
M: Boyd, McDonald, Zorko  - Selwood, Pendlebury  - Ablett, Horsley  - Thompson
R: Cox, Giles  - Stephenson - Redden
F: Dangerfield, Treloar  - Pavlich, Beams, Chapman  - Franklin, Martin, Hall, Saad

Leaves me with only 5 trades left but a pretty strong side (7/5/1/6) with only 2 of horsley/treloar/zorko/mcdonald and giles as rookies on field with top 6-10 players on each line. With 5 trades left will look at going horse/mcd > rookie/murphy when he bottoms out and if all goes to plan hopefully upgrading a forward in the finals. realise i have used all my trades but i have gone with the motto of trade hard, trade fast to get a team in in a carnage of a season.. hopefully it all goes to plan!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on May 28, 2012, 09:42:18 AM
Round 9 Score: 2233

Winners:
pretty good week across the park really. Deledio and Shaw led the defence with serviceable outputs from Goddard, Lake and Scotland. Pendlebury did great in the mids compared to other peoples captains, Boyd was at his best and Selwood keeps on performing. In the rucks Giles continues to press his claims for a permenant spot on my team, while in the forward line we couldnt look past Dayne Beams and him being the sole reason i was able to score so highly this week! Pavlich, Martin and Chapman also bounced back while have to heap praise on Saad and Treloar breaking the ton.

Sinners:
Malceski had a nightmare of a game, while Franklin and Cox didnt reach their lofty heights
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on May 28, 2012, 10:52:28 AM
Looking to move on two of Porplyzia, Morris, Mohr and to a lesser extent Adams

have plenty of mpp in the mid/fwd so im thinking of getting Dal Santo in for Porplyzia
was looking at upgrading another mid for Adams but i can trade out either Morris or Mohr for Waters which i think is my best bet. both trades wouldnt hurt my bye structure and it would finish off my backline, leaving only two midfield upgrades left for the season (looking at scotty t after round 11 and ablett after round 13).

What do you think?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: Slammer on May 28, 2012, 04:41:07 PM
How many trades you have?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on May 28, 2012, 04:56:42 PM
10!
not many but i wanted to try something different this year as i feel i have been too conservative in the past
i have moved 24k places in the rankings in 4 weeks so it seems to be working.. if i have it my way then i should have 4-5 trades left after the byes in case of long term injury etc.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on May 30, 2012, 10:39:25 AM
           Porplyzia > Dal Santo          Morris > Waters

__________________Round 10_________________

__________________Round 11_________________

       Adams > Priddis     McDonald > GWS rookie? (M/F?)

__________________Round 12_________________

               Horsley > Round 11/12 rookie (M/F?)

__________________Round 13_________________

Treloar > Ablett or if i cant afford him.. Swan/Thompson/etc.

Sound good peoples?? done my homework and getting Ablett will all depend on Priddiss score next week, as well as rookie performance and the great man himself, however im pretty close if my calculations are correct..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 01, 2012, 02:07:44 PM
DOUBLE UPGRADE-TIME!

definitely doing Morris > Waters leaving me with a settled backline for the rest of the year with Mohr and Ellis covering

tossing up between Dal Santo and Cotchin coming in for Porplyzia.. who do people think is better? thinking Dal as i need as much money saved as i can if i want to get Ablett in after the byes, but what does everyone else think?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: NoButYeah on June 01, 2012, 03:09:14 PM
Neither. McLean!! Has the same bye...

But seriously, both great scorers but NDS a bit cheaper so I'd go with him.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 03, 2012, 11:44:22 PM
Round 10 Score - 2258

Winners: large numbers up forward with Buddy, Chappy, Danger and Beams chipping in as well as a solid 93 by Pav. Low midfield numbers didnt help with Dal Santo and Pendlebury getting under 100 and Selwood, Boyd and Zorks just getting over it.. Horsley beign subbed didnt help my scoring either. Down back was of greatest concern though.. apart from Deledio and Goddard there wasnt much happiness with Waters, Scotland, Lake and the exclusions of Malceski and Shaw hurting me greatly. lucky Cox had a good day out and savoured something for me :P good thing is I only lost one of my games! :D
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 08, 2012, 11:40:16 AM
Final Bye Plan Strategy - I think  :-\

Starting Team

B: Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, Shaw, Waters, Lake, Malceski <Ellis, Mohr>
M: Pendlebury, Selwood, Boyd, Dal Santo, Horsley, Adams <McDonald, Zorko>
R: Cox, Giles <Stephenson, Redden>
F: Franklin, Dangerfield, Chapman, Beams, Pavlich, Martin, Treloar <Saad, Hall>

Starting with $45k in the kitty

Horsley > Sexton          +$198k          $242k in the kitty

Round 11

Mohr > Sam Shaw        +$185k
Adams > Priddis            -$166k           $261k in the kitty

Round 12

Saad > Cloke                -$75k             $186k in the kitty

Round 13

Treloar > Morabito       +211k
McDonald > Ablett       +340k             186 + 211 + 340 = $737k - Should have approx. above $700k which will be enough to get Ablett

If I am struggling for money I will look at bringing in possibly Clifton instead of Morabito, and if struggling more so will get a $113k rookie

Donuts for byes look like 6/2/2 which includes Scotland missing them all and banking on Shaw and Pendles coming back in round 13

Team wil be as follows -

B: Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, H.Shaw, Waters, Lake, Malceski <Ellis, S.Shaw>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Selwood, Boyd, Dal Santo, Priddis <Morabito, Sexton>
R: Cox, Giles <Stephenson, Redden>
F: Franklin, Dangerfield, Pavlich, Chapman, Martin, Beams, Cloke <Hall, Zorko>

will have 2 trades for the rest of the season to save for finals but will be tempted to go Giles > Mumford when Brogan comes back and Mumford reaches full fitness

What do people think? Sound plan?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on June 08, 2012, 11:45:33 AM
whats the before team look like?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 08, 2012, 11:50:24 AM
whats the before team look like?

updated now charlie!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on June 08, 2012, 11:55:00 AM
How many trades left?  Going for league wins mainly?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 08, 2012, 11:57:33 AM
How many trades left?  Going for league wins mainly?

i will have 2 trades left after all of this, 8 at the start of this week
going for league win but have taken this season as a bit of an experiment and trading hard to get a team early as i can. i think i have been too conservative in the past and wanted to play to the other extreme
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on June 08, 2012, 11:58:16 AM
I think you need to get GAJ in right now.  Don't delay this

McDonald > Sexton
Horsley > Ablett
Scotland > Premium defender maybe Birchall/Newman/MJ that gives you cash to get GAJ.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 08, 2012, 12:03:13 PM
I think you need to get GAJ in right now.  Don't delay this

McDonald > Sexton
Horsley > Ablett
Scotland > Premium defender maybe Birchall/Newman/MJ that gives you cash to get GAJ.

not too worried about scotlands injury and dont want to be trading premium players out. firmly focused on the finals, looking good in all my leagues, and using trades to get a few bargain premiums that revolve around helping me through the bye rounds.. do you think it is a sound plan? much that can go wrong?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on June 08, 2012, 12:12:48 PM
Haven't done the maths, is this possible?

SCotland > Newman
McDonald > Sexton
Horsley > Ablett

Waiting 3 rounds for Ablett is painful.  Sometimes you have to swallow your pride and sideways trade for greater good of your team.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 08, 2012, 01:14:29 PM
3 rounds of byes though.. everyone is in the same boat
the trades you have put up look good but i think i might hold out.. trying to plan around byes etc.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on June 08, 2012, 01:27:39 PM
This is GAJ we are talking about.  No idea what GAJ could do in those 3 rounds.  He could potentially offset donuts through captaincy alone.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on June 08, 2012, 01:30:19 PM
R11 team - 3 Donuts - Shaw, Pendlebury, Waters

B: Deledio, Goddard, Newman, Shaw, Waters, Ellis, Malceski <Lake, Mohr>
M: Pendlebury, Selwood, Boyd, Dal Santo, GAJ, Sexton <Adams, Zorko>
R: Stephenson, Redden <Cox, Giles>
F: Franklin, Hall, Chapman, Beams, Pavlich, Martin, Saad <Treloar, Dangerfield>

Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 08, 2012, 04:32:27 PM
had a play around with it but it impacts my plans too much plus i dont see the long term benefits of trading out scotland when what i want is a league win

thanks for the thoughts CS but im going to try and work it my way
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 11, 2012, 08:53:08 AM
Knew this week would be bad but I could never have guessed this bad! Some terrible scores from premiums and some horrible scores from rookies has me ended up with 1288 with Dayne Beams to come.. Hopefully hittin above 1400.. Hopefully my next two rounds don't follow suit!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: Ringo on June 11, 2012, 12:14:22 PM
Knew this week would be bad but I could never have guessed this bad! Some terrible scores from premiums and some horrible scores from rookies has me ended up with 1288 with Dayne Beams to come.. Hopefully hittin above 1400.. Hopefully my next two rounds don't follow suit!
+1 We may end up with similar scores after this weekend.  I am on 1236 with Beams and Magner to come.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 12, 2012, 07:40:57 AM
Round 11 Score - 1428

Shaw, Pendles and Scotland gave me 5 donuts for the round which hurt. Tiger players down on their averages and terrible rookie scores killed any hope of doing well. If it wasn't for Captain Selwood I could have been in a lot of trouble! Still won 3/5 leagues so I'm happy :)

B: Goddard, Deledio, Mohr, Lake, Ellis, Waters, Scotland <Shaw, Malceski>
M: Boyd, Dal Santo, Zorko, McDonald, Adams, Sexton <Pendlebury, Selwood>
R: Cox, Giles <Redden, Stephenson>
F: Franklin, Martin, Dangerfield, Saad, Hall, Treloar, Pavlich <Chapman, Beams>

$242k in kitty, 7 trades remaining

Looking at going Mohr or Ellis > Sam Shaw and then Adams > Priddis

Thoughts?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 14, 2012, 09:47:45 AM
okay so i have gone for a different tactic..

team is as follows

B: Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, Shaw, Waters, Lake, Malceski <Mohr, Ellis>
M: Pendlebury, Selwood, Boyd, Dal Santo, McDonald, Zorko <Adams, Sexton>
R: Cox, Giles <Redden, Stephenson>
F: Franklin, Dangerfield, Beams, Pavlich, Martin, Chapman, Treloar <Saad, Hall>

$241k remaining and 7 trades to go..

definitely doing the Mohr > Shaw trade if he is named which gives me $425k in the kitty
now I was thinking about getting Priddis in this week for Adams but im thinking of holding off and bringing in Sidebottom next week instead.. the remaining money (approx. $125k) will allow me to trade in Ablett after round 13 (McDonald> Gibson, Treloar>Ablett) and then hopefully Scott Thompson when he drops in price, but only when Zorko and Saad have reached culling price! (Saad>Rookie, Zorko>Thompson)

trade plan is as follows

Round 11
Mohr > S.Shaw                                     $425 in the kitty
Round 12
Adams > Sidebottom                             $125 in the kitty
Round 13
McDonald >Gibson    Treloar > Ablett      hopefully still $125 in the kitty
Round 14
GET SCOTT THOMPSON!!

what do people think?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: Ringo on June 14, 2012, 09:56:12 AM
Would be perfect except for one small problem.  Only leaves you one trade for rest of season. May struggle through with that but not ideal.  Your decision though.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 14, 2012, 10:23:16 AM
will i still be able to make the above trade after tonights lockout?

having sidebottom in my fwds is my number 1 priority i think.. he easily has the best average of the fwds i dont have and is pretty much like having an extra premium mid. ablett is also another player that i have to have, pulls out huge numbers and will consistently.. i suppose with the money i have left over i could try and make one trade out of it to finish off my mids..

another option is getting in adam goodes as a straight swap for ahmed saad after this round. it would leave me with little to no money yet would sve a trade in the long run

sidebottom vs. goodes? if it means saving a trade maybe goodes is the way to go..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 15, 2012, 07:39:05 AM
Would be perfect except for one small problem.  Only leaves you one trade for rest of season. May struggle through with that but not ideal.  Your decision though.

Decided to do just the Ringo! Made the Hall > Priddis trade after he wasn't named and Adams was but also traded Mohr down to Sam Shaw. I should be able to get Ablett without taking money out of my $200k kitty through Treloar and Jmac an that $200 will go towards a straight swap for Sidebottom once he comes back down in price again hopefully.. Realistically the only rookie who would be able to do that would be Zorko but I'm hoping one of Saad or Adams pulls out a big game and rises for me at the right time
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 15, 2012, 08:33:43 AM
Would be perfect except for one small problem.  Only leaves you one trade for rest of season. May struggle through with that but not ideal.  Your decision though.

Decided to do just the Ringo! Made the Hall > Priddis trade after he wasn't named and Adams was but also traded Mohr down to Sam Shaw. I should be able to get Ablett without taking money out of my $200k kitty through Treloar and Jmac an that $200 will go towards a straight swap for Sidebottom once he comes back down in price again hopefully.. Realistically the only rookie who would be able to do that would be Zorko but I'm hoping one of Saad or Adams pulls out a big game and rises for me at the right time

Final team should look like this..

B: Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, Shaw, Waters, Lake, Malceski <Ellis, Shaw>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Selwood, Boyd, Priddis, Dal Santo <Adams, Gibson>
R: Cox, Giles <Redden, Stephenson>
F: Franklin, Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Chapman, Martin, Pavlich, Beams <Zorko, Sexton>

2 trades left

Strong side?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 15, 2012, 11:51:33 AM
Hey there f-man,

Taking the 131 from Priddis?  ;)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 15, 2012, 12:23:57 PM
Most definitely, I don't tempt fate! How is your team looking coming up to the tank round?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 15, 2012, 12:36:48 PM
Whilst it looks like I am tanking every round, I am not.

Worst year ever.

Still, am a sneaky chance to bring some awesome team down this week!

Ended up not tanking one round due to percentage concerns.

Good luck - not a lot - just a bit.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 15, 2012, 11:33:08 PM
Saad about Saad.  :(
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 16, 2012, 02:15:59 PM
Will probably lose a few games this week.. Jeez the late withdrawals kill you in the bye rounds!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 17, 2012, 09:31:03 PM
1849 for my round 12 score!

lost most of my leagues but won the one i care about against my bext mate!!
Winners - Cox, Priddis (good inclusion this week!), Dal stepping up in the last quarter, Scotland and Deledio down back, Franklin, Boyd, a huge match by Zorko!! and my hero of the week... ALEX SEXTON!! without his late inclusion i would have lost my game by 3 measly points!!

Sinners - can't believe Treloar... maybe a downgrade to Gibson this week and an upgrade for JMac to Ablett in round 14.. will leave me with about 150k in the bank and zorko and giles as my playing rookies which i dont mind leaving. my team will be set for finals!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 17, 2012, 09:48:55 PM
big question... should treloar be traded?? was always going to be part of the ablett trade after this next round but i might have to downgrade him to gibson a week early and make some cash..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: Ringo on June 17, 2012, 10:06:59 PM
I would trade him this week as he will loose further cash this week with a high B/e but your decision.
Are you still on target for that team with only 2 trades left
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 17, 2012, 11:48:26 PM
 ;)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 18, 2012, 01:02:28 AM
I would trade him this week as he will loose further cash this week with a high B/e but your decision.
Are you still on target for that team with only 2 trades left

thinking of getting ablett in for treloar and jmac after round 13 and leaving zorko as f7
will leave me with three trades that barring injury would let me upgrade zorko and giles to mumford and sidey come finals
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: Ringo on June 18, 2012, 08:35:39 AM
Nice  final trade like all of us hoping Zorko keeps it up and no reason at this point to doubt.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 20, 2012, 04:15:52 PM
with Adam Treloar looking like losing me money this week i will probably trade him down to Sam Gibson, upgrading JMac to Ablett the week after

Final team..

B: Deledio, Goddard, H.Shaw, Scotland, Waters, Lake, Malceski <S.Shaw, Ellis>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, J.Selwood, Boyd, Priddis, Dal Santo <Gibson, Adams>
R: Cox, Giles <Stephenson, Redden>
F: Franklin, Dangerfield, Chapman, Beams, Pavlich, Martin, Zorko <Saad, Sexton>

approx. $140k remaining and 3 trades left over for finals
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 20, 2012, 04:35:09 PM
Good afternoon feisty one,

Treloar is a dilemma. Was scoring so well and then bang - has he hit the wall?

If he is left out, then no need to pull the trigger. Tempting to keep him even if picked as he may drop a bit but if you're happy with 72 ppg from your F8/9 then cool.
 
I wonder whether you might end up trading Sexton or Saad instead. Avoids a donut and neither really worth starting anyway.

Obviously Ablett after his bye. Your other rookies are still making money so good.

Get Couch for a donut in forwards if picked?

You need Sidey at some stage I would think.

Giles should be OK for R2 - unless you've got heaps of trades. The difference between him and say Mumford probably less than between a rested gun and a M7 or 8.

Oh the pain.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 20, 2012, 05:05:36 PM
if thats the case doctor what do you think about a saad downgrade to gibson and run with treloar, zorko, adams and sexton as my gap fillers on the bench?

thing is with the treloar trade it gives me 140k after the jmac > ablett trade to hopefully upgrade zorko to sidebottom once he is within reach, only using one trade..

it doesnt bother me with saad on the bench as cover because i think his js and scoring potential isnt too bad..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 20, 2012, 05:20:49 PM
Yes that works for me.

My reluctance to dump Treloar is due to the very same reason you are tempted to - his good scoring has increased his price by quite a lot. So in a convoluted way we agree. My rationale to keep is to have him as really good cover so predicted price drop is of no significance.

Saad has the bye and a I don't think he'll score much more than Treloar.

Sexton is the worst of them all however.

If you do some calculations, can you afford Sidey and keep Saad and Treloar?

Also are this week's league matches as tough as last week's which were very easy for some?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 20, 2012, 05:31:30 PM
im thinking of getting in ablett next week and not sidey..

im happy with zorko as f7 for the time being and really the only thing that is making me choose to trade treloar apart from saad is the money.. think that extra $40k could come in handy.. not even looking at trading sexton because i think he is a flexible mover for my bench, allowing me to put adams or zorko onto either part of the mid/fwd line. no point trading him when that is pretty much the whole reason i got him in
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 20, 2012, 06:45:09 PM
Wouldn't it be nice to be able to get on the Couch?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 08:26:47 AM
Jeez Malceski is doing my head in! Surely he is in Sydney's best 21! Don't know what I will do with him..
This makes the Treloar to Gibson trade all the more important so I have the funds to possibly upgrade him if need be.. The only problem is the only viable option I would look at is Carazzo after Round 14 when he bottoms out, but should I just bank on Eski getting back in the side and playing good footy?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 09:55:16 AM
ESKI OPTIONS! ~ approx. $463,000 to spend this week

This week..

Heppell     $409k     BE: 112
Murphy     $430k     BE: 49
Enright     $453k     BE: 118

Next week +

Suckling   $403k     BE: 40
Fisher      $434k     BE: 132
Newman  $392k     BE: 125

And the others...

Birchall    $467k     BE: 102
Broughts  $466k     BE: 83
Carrazzo  $465k     BE: 150

at the moment im thinking about holding him.. dont want to make a knee jerk reaction in the bye rounds for the short term plus there are a lot of good premiums falling in price!
looking at Carrazzo, Heppell, Enright, Fisher, Birchall after round 13 or when they start to bottom out

Eski seems like a huge risk now, when he does get into the side next will probably only be the sub anyway and lose more money with a breakeven of 124

im very short on trades (5 remaining at the start of this week) but at the moment he is the only weakness in my side

what do people think about nick? is he done for or will he make his way back in the strong side and regain his 80+ average? also will ellis or shaw be able to cover for him if i do wait for him to come back?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on June 22, 2012, 01:29:22 PM
Wait one more week.

If Malceksi is selected, just go straight to Rance
If Malceski is not selected, wait another week for Carrots.

Rance won't be rested, already averaging 90+, and Dylan Grimes coming back into team.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 22, 2012, 03:26:57 PM
Just for something completely different.

Tip out the Eski.

Treloar as well.

About $809K - yeah?

Get Patton (or whoever as forward bench cover) and defender of your choice.

Then only Ablett and Sidey / Goodes to go.

Cheers and good luck.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 03:28:09 PM
hadnt thought of rance! cheers cs.. and yeah leaning towards just leaving it for a week and reassessing next week..
jmac > ablett is already going to take one trade but the malceski dilemma has thrown my plans out..

is there any hope for him to regain his spot in the side?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 03:30:00 PM
Just for something completely different.

Tip out the Eski.

Treloar as well.

About $809K - yeah?

Get Patton (or whoever as forward bench cover) and defender of your choice.

Then only Ablett and Sidey / Goodes to go.

Cheers and good luck.

ill have a play with it now and check it out doctor.. just messing around with players
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 03:34:13 PM
Treloar > Gibson
Saad > Sidebottom
Malceski > Johnson?

only leaves me with two trades :S
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on June 22, 2012, 03:39:06 PM
Gotta pick up GAJ.  Might have to miss out on Carrots, it might be worth just upgrading Malceski this round so you can grab GAJ week after.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 03:45:14 PM
Gotta pick up GAJ.  Might have to miss out on Carrots.

just realised if i get ablett there is no way i can afford carrazzo for malceski without another downgrade somewhere would scott thompson be a better bet, leaving me enough money to upgrade malceski to carrazzoo if need be?

im starting to lean toward just leaving malceski in the side and hope he comes up trumps later on in the season
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 22, 2012, 03:46:28 PM
Saad still making money? If so, then hold unless you want to avoid a donut.

Gibson gives you $$ but is it necessary given running low on trades?

Treloar is the one to offload if you are looking for $$.

Sidey won't rise a lot but will a decent Treloar drop put him out of reach?

Got to plan for Ablett.

Maybe sit with Eski this week.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 03:52:40 PM
was just thinking that doctor..

double downgrade treloar and saad? gibson and crozier?

would give me $651k in the kitty for my last 3 trades... $335k for my last 2 once i get ablett in.. this would give me a lot of flexibility as to who i get in for malceski if i needed to ditch him, or even upgrade ellis once he hits his peak!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 22, 2012, 03:58:26 PM
Better long term plan IMO.

I'll be watching you.  8)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 04:05:42 PM
hmm... interesting.. would it maybe be better to wait on saad til he makes a bit more $$ and grab (im going to say it...) couch (there i said it!!) when/IF he comes onto the scene!! even if i just dg him to delollio or something ill still have adams and sexton rotating through my bench.. that way i can just wait a while and assess the malceski situation as well
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 04:31:22 PM
only the one trade but dont know which one to pick...

treloar > crozier?

or

treloar > gibson?

leading toward crozier.. still gives me dpp flexibility and my reasoning behind not doing both is that i dont think saad is ready to be culled just yet
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on June 22, 2012, 04:40:26 PM
Gibson.  How much cash left over if you grab GAJ?

Maybe have to cop Malceski on the chin unless you wanna gamble on a mid-pricer.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 22, 2012, 04:46:22 PM
Gibson over Crozier.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 22, 2012, 04:48:32 PM
will have about 130k left over once i get in ablett next week.. dependant on how well mcdonald plays
if mcdonald does play well and continues to make money i may be able to keep him and upgrade saad
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 24, 2012, 07:41:58 PM
1570 this week and won all my leagues! :D
this week getting ablett in for jmac and then possibly looking at getting rid of malceski..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 25, 2012, 08:24:57 AM
You must have been pleased with S Shaw and Gibson!!

But I guess you weren't alone.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 25, 2012, 10:05:23 AM
yeah they were good hey! lol
won all my league games so no problems there ;)

what do you think doctor?
ablett this week for jmac and carrazzo week after for malceski? will leave me with 2 trades remaining that ill save..

team will be as follows:

B: Deledio, H.Shaw, Goddard, Scotland, Carrazzo, Waters, Lake <Ellis, S.Shaw>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, J.Selwood, Boyd, Priddis, Dal Santo <Gibson, Adams>
R: Cox, Giles <Stephenson, Redden>
F: Franklin, Beams, Dangerfield, Chapman, Pavlich, Martin, Zorko <Saad, Sexton>
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 25, 2012, 10:17:27 AM
Yes.

Just have to hope S Shaw and Gibbo get games after this weekend's performance / subbing.

Lucky Zorko has come along.


Also Giles had better keep on going or we're in trouble.

Definitely need Ablett, so yes.

Not sure on Carrazzo though. I prefer Birchall but Carrazzo will drop a lot after the next 2 weeks.

Good wins by the sound of it.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 25, 2012, 10:51:47 AM
carrazzo average 100+ if you take out his injured six.. consistent so fatr
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 27, 2012, 05:39:38 PM
tossing up between getting carrazzo or newman for malceski.. i know this is probably a decision for next week, so long as nick doesnt get named, but what are peoples thoughts.. is it better to keep a bit of cash handy so that its easier to upgrade the likes of giles if he does start petering out..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 27, 2012, 05:59:08 PM
looking to do these trades to finalise my team..

McDonald > Ablett
Giles > Mumford
Malceski > ?

good trades? what do people think of the mumford trade? is he too much of a risk??
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: colmullet on June 27, 2012, 06:24:51 PM
i think he's to risky, pulled up sore in the 4th quarter last week n i wouldnt rely on him playing every game from here on out
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 27, 2012, 07:49:02 PM
Newman = no.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 28, 2012, 06:48:04 PM
Definitely doing the JMac > Ablett Trade!

Leaves me with 3 trades left..

couple of options after that..

1. Malceski > Suckling, Broughton, Enright?
2. Giles > Jacobs, Mumford, Griffin?
3. hold trades and get Carrazzo in for Malceski the week after, look at funds for Giles after that

Malceski looks to be on the outer and need to get rid of him ASAP! good cover this week with Ellis and Shaw in the wings..
Giles seems to be really struggling and hasnt played well alongside Brogan this year with scores of 81, 106, 56, 54 and seems to be tapering off a bit
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 29, 2012, 12:19:06 AM
Ablett BE = 146
McDonald BE = 65 (According to tooserious.net)

Do you need the extra 60 points this week?

If not, you might be better taking a chance and you could end up with an extra $10K or so.

Not many trades left which means it is hard to harvest those rookies.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 29, 2012, 04:04:55 PM
I have been delaying the inevitable for too long doctor.. Need him in! Jmac has been lucky to get over 60 the past couple of weeks and def won't go up much more.. What do you think about the other trades?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 30, 2012, 12:23:41 AM
You can get Carrots $20k cheaper next week. Well done.

Doesn't it feel good slapping that big fat hairy juicy C on Ablett?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on June 30, 2012, 11:00:02 AM
Already looking to next week...

Yarran + Maric vs. Carrazzo + Mumford vs. Heppell + Jacobs...

Some big combinations to finish off the year!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on June 30, 2012, 06:42:35 PM
Ouch - Ablett captain.  ;)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 02, 2012, 01:09:22 PM
alright so here is the deal..
which of these is the better combination

Chris Newman & Sam Jacobs/Ben McEvoy      80 + 100 = 180
Heppell & Mumford                                      80 + 100 = 180
Carrazzo/Enright/Hanley/Adcock & Giles         90 + 70 = 160
Hibberd & Ryder                                          85 + 110 = 195
Yarran & Maric/Natanui                                80 + 115 = 195

wanting to get rid of Giles and Malceski and finalise my team

stefan martin? lobbe?

Here is the poll - http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,63873.0.html
ATM Maric and Yarran are winning!!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on July 02, 2012, 08:56:33 PM
I like the McEvoy option.  Surely got to be other defenders in Newman price range?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 02, 2012, 09:02:01 PM
I wonder whether you are able to just do the one upgrade this week?

Hang on to Giles and just get Enright or whoever you like eg Carrots in for Malceski.

Sexton gone I think which means you need to think about being a bit more conservative.

Saad was luck to play, Buddy could miss and with Sexton out you'll get a feed if you're unlucky. For instance if Chapman misses again.

Hold Giles for now.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 02, 2012, 09:36:51 PM
With eski possibly earning a recall I think I would rather trade Giles! Lol sexton no big loss.. Only wanted him for his mpp anyway
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - BYE STRATEGY - Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 03, 2012, 05:17:23 PM
If malceski is named what are people's thoughts on if he can stay in the side?
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 03, 2012, 10:21:37 PM
With only 3 trades left, I think it a luxurious indulgence to ditch your Eski if he is named.

Sexton gone. Saad JS? General Soreness fast approaching. Buddy doubtful. 2012 the year of the injury. Goddard in trouble isn't he? Scotland to face the legal system. Pendlebury not 100%. S Shaw JS? Redden and Biggo not in favour. Giles?

I truly deeply think you have bigger fish to fry.

Hold onto your Eski in times like these.
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 04, 2012, 12:46:32 PM
well if thats the case would you trade giles to Ryder with $8k remaining or Sam Jacobs with his easy run in the finals which leaves me with $44k
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 04, 2012, 01:09:56 PM
I think Ryder can score higher but can drift out a bit, especially if they play 3 talks and Hurley becomes their main focal point. He has looked good lately.

Jacobs for reliability and a bit extra cash.
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 04, 2012, 03:17:54 PM
Good point about the ruck.. What do you think about Ben McEvoy now that Blake and Stanley have both gone down?
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 04, 2012, 05:24:50 PM
good enough final side?

B: Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, H.Shaw, Waters, Lake, Malceski <Ellis, S.Shaw>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, J.Selwood, Boyd, Priddis, Dal Santo <Gibson, Adams>
R: Cox, Jacobs <Redden, Stephenson>
F: Franklin, Beams, Dangerfield, Chapman, Pavlich, Martin, Zorko <Saad, Sexton>

2 trades and 44k remaining
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 04, 2012, 06:26:02 PM
You of all people should know Saints are stuffed.
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 04, 2012, 06:39:49 PM
hahaha i know they're stuffed but is mcevoy? ;)
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: jamesalex on July 04, 2012, 11:12:07 PM
Im in a similar situation as you, in that i have Eski and Giles, but have limited trades. Are you comfortable with having 2 trades left for the season? Im making a midfield upgrade next round, and have to decide whether i want to upgrade Eski/Giles as well. It completes my team (pretty much), but is 2 trades too little? Just something to think about..
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 05, 2012, 08:22:06 AM
I'm just thinking about if the trade is worth it? Do people think malceski can be a starter for the season at the swans?
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on July 05, 2012, 01:33:03 PM
Trade is not the issue.  The question is who you bring in for the same price.
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 05, 2012, 04:37:00 PM
well charlie i wanted to keep that one quiet.. ill pm you
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 06, 2012, 09:32:19 AM
Yarran and Maric
Yarran and Ryder and $95k
Yarran and Jacobs and $130k

1 trade remaining after this!!
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 06, 2012, 10:22:38 AM
Would you rather Yarran and NO trades or Malceski and ONE trade?

That is what you will be facing.

Sideways = no ways.

Hold hold hold.

My opinion only.
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 06, 2012, 01:38:59 PM
Currently sitting 1, 2, 1, 3, 4 in my 5 leagues and not sure whether I can keep that going if I don't make a move on malceski soon.. It's not really a sideways trade if a player isn't playing
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 06, 2012, 02:24:43 PM
True, but surely he will play again and then when you get a LTI you will watch him and weep.
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 06, 2012, 02:39:50 PM
Wise words doctor.. Yarran is still cheap so if he is in my price range in two/three weeks time and eski still isn't playing I could grab him then.. One Trade - Giles > Jacobs
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 06, 2012, 07:36:04 PM
Second thoughts about Malceski...
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 07, 2012, 05:43:37 AM
Souls have listened to myself an jumped on Yarran :(
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 07, 2012, 04:41:25 PM
Got some good news for you!

Eski IN
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 08, 2012, 03:54:57 PM
Got some good news for you!

Eski IN

Loved the result! :) Ellis > Yarran??
Title: Re: NEED HELP WITH MALCESKI!!! FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 08, 2012, 07:40:51 PM
Round 15     Score: 2622

Massive round with Cox, Pavlich and Priddis all breaking the 170 for me.. great games also by both Shaws, new inclusion hitout-king Jacobs, Dal Santo, Chappy, Captain Selwood, the Little Master and Boydy!

still had a few rookies taking the spots of Goddard, Waters, Martin and Pendlebury but you can't complain about that..

this week I'll either be looking at trading ellis or shaw to yarran or just sitting on my two trades until the finals
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 08, 2012, 09:18:57 PM
Good enough final team?

B: Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, Shaw, Waters, Lake, Malceski <Ellis, Shaw>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Jelwood, Boyd, Priddis, Dal Santo <Gibson, Sexton>
R: Cox, Jacobs <Redden, Stephenson>
F: Franklin, Beams, Chapman, Dangerfield, Pavlich, Martin, Zorko <Saad, Adams>

2 trades remaining!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 09, 2012, 12:12:48 AM
2622 - got to get Ledger.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on July 09, 2012, 06:18:52 PM
Strong team.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 10, 2012, 07:05:34 PM
think i need to make any changes?

waters > yarran and keep cash for last trade?
ellis > yarran in case malceski gets dropped again?
just sit and wait?

i am happy to cover waters and franklin, hard when goddard and martin are out as well but its only one week and they'll be back
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 10, 2012, 09:15:17 PM
Adios agua
Arriverderci acqua
Auf wiedersehn wasser
Selamat jalan air

No use crying over split Waters. He's gawn.

But who to come in?

Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 11, 2012, 05:26:52 PM
why trade waters though doctor? with only 2 trades left i cant really afford it
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on July 11, 2012, 07:57:29 PM
Risky keeping players with an injury history.

Look at Zaha and how much it has dragged on, and he played every game last year  :-[
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 12, 2012, 12:07:30 AM
why trade waters though doctor? with only 2 trades left i cant really afford it

I am thinking that you'll need to once finals start and you run a higher risk of donuts with him clogging your bench.

And resting likely.

No rush I guess.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 13, 2012, 08:35:54 AM
Surely they won't rest him with 4 games to get his match fitness back before finals! I'm still on the fence.. What to do what to do!!?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 13, 2012, 09:15:37 AM
I mean resting OTHER players. Say like Shaw Shaw or Scotland.

Also Malceski seems a bit of a fringe player nowadays and Ellis will tire as well.

Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 13, 2012, 12:14:16 PM
what do you think of ellis > yarran?

leaving my backline - Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, H.Shaw, Waters, Lake, Yarran <Malceski, S.Shaw>
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on July 13, 2012, 12:24:30 PM
Not the worst idea.

TBH, I would just sideways trade Waters > Carrots.  Guaranteed 100's, rather than volatile scoring of Yaz.



Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 13, 2012, 12:30:58 PM
even with only two trades left? think i might just sit
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: charliesheen on July 13, 2012, 12:32:52 PM
Yes, trade Waters.  When you have an injury prone player, you cut your losses asap and move on.  His done his job.

I would rather take a 100% guaranteed premium like Carrots (top 4 easily) and back your rookies to come through when needed. 
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 13, 2012, 02:07:09 PM
Hmm.. Decisions decisions..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 13, 2012, 05:58:46 PM
Waters is on thin ice!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 13, 2012, 06:01:13 PM
Why though? Just had the arthroscope and will be back in business in 4 weeks.. If it really is I problem I can trade him then ;) would hate to trade someone in and they got injured in the next 4 weeks
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 15, 2012, 08:08:42 PM
no trades this week (first time this year!  :o) and managed 2457!

may look to do no trades again, however Malceski is still a worry.. might play Sam Shaw off the bench in front of him
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 19, 2012, 08:34:00 AM
Chance for Waters to return in next weeks game against Brisbane! :D
Glad I didn't trade him off now
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 19, 2012, 12:45:30 PM
Nice prognostication there fell sty!

What if Eski is out this week?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 19, 2012, 02:45:20 PM
Dunno.. You think he is a chance? Played a solid game
McGuane two 90-100 games in a row in the forward line..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 20, 2012, 02:40:36 PM
Sit on my team I think.. Been scoring above 2400 since I finished my team and hopefully Waters, Martin and Goddard only add to that potential scoring!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 20, 2012, 03:21:19 PM
Yes. Sit this week.

Make sure you have an E to cover Waters!

Bet you wish you didn't get NDS - a bargain!

See you in the finals?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 20, 2012, 03:27:02 PM
Might have been better to hold off for Murphy or Thompson however Im optimistic for the rest of Dals season.. It's not about his average earlier in the season.. Is about his average from now on! Although I DO keep saying that every week :S
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 22, 2012, 09:42:22 PM
well dal didnt go much better did he :S

2333 for the round.. lost two games against the highest scores in the league for the round which hurt but other than that it was painless!

great games from ablett, pav and beamsy
scotland, pendlebury, danger and zorks were very good and priddis and shaw were handy
the saints killed me in goddard, dal santo and saad. boyd, selwood and chapman were also below their best..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: Jay on July 25, 2012, 09:46:03 PM
You two have a weird relationship felst and doc :P

Good luck in finals mate :)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 25, 2012, 11:46:29 PM
Hey felsteiner

I thought this was a private chat room!

J welcome though.

Season building with trades at a premium and resting about to begin.

2012's only saving grace could well be the result of the socialisation of the AFL - the salary cap!

Has made the competition tighter with meaningful matches taking place a lot longer into the season. Top 4, home ground finals and top 8 places to fight for means maybe 'The General' won't come to play as much as in the last few years.

Best of luck for the last few rounds and Go Hawks - hopefully playing Saints in the Granny!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 26, 2012, 08:55:09 AM
Could be  good but highly doubtful!

A man can always dream can't he? If they played ledger the would be a certainty!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 27, 2012, 11:12:16 AM
No trades this week.. Hopefully Ledger gets a run  ;D
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 27, 2012, 12:30:05 PM
Go on - trade.

You know you want to.

Have you really still got Ledger?

Good luck.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 27, 2012, 07:01:27 PM
Have you really still got Ledger?

What do you think? :P
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: Jay on July 27, 2012, 07:09:53 PM
ledger didnt get named
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on July 27, 2012, 11:43:54 PM
Felsty too smart to still have Ledger.

Enjoyed the game tonight.  :)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on July 30, 2012, 10:05:06 AM
2544 for the round copping the one donut for Sauce Jacobs
Winners all over the board so I might as well pick on the weaker aspects.. Lake had a dog of a day (no pun intended) and Malceski wasn't much better.. Defense is clearly the weakest link and probably the place where I will be upgrading come finals time if I'm able to stay injury free.. Good to see Dal Santo finally hit some form!

Lets hope Franklin and Jacobs are back and I have a full strength side again!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 01, 2012, 09:29:19 AM
Happy just to sit and wait on my two trades
Can anyone see any areas I might want to focus on?

B: Goddard, Deledio, Scotland, H.Shaw, Waters, Lake, Malceski <Ellis, S.Shaw>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Boyd, Priddis, Dal Santo, Jelwood <Gibson, Sexton>
R: Cox, Jacobs <Redden, Stephenson>
F: Franklin, Beams, Dangerfield, Pavlich, Chapman, Martin, Zorko <Saad, Adams>

$40k left
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: Ringo on August 01, 2012, 12:35:21 PM
Just keep an eye on the form of Dal Santo, Martin and maybe Eski and that will give you a guide.
Strong Team with no real need to trade unless 100% necessary.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 02, 2012, 12:02:45 PM
Mm.. Dal and Mal are the two stooges :P
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 03, 2012, 12:22:30 PM
could be a very interesting week with rumours buddy may miss the port game as well.. if that happens a certain trade down to lewis, rioli or roughead might have to be on the cards.. would give me a bit more money to upgrade my last position too!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 06, 2012, 11:53:20 AM
Trade out Malceski or Lake? Probably my two weeks links at the moment.. I have made top 4 in all my leagues and have two trades left..

B: Goddard, Deledio, Scotland, Waters, H.Shaw, Lake, Malceski <Ellis, S.Shaw>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Jelwood, Boyd, Priddis, Dal Santo <Gibson, Sexton>
R: Cox, Jacobs <Stephenson, Redden>
F: Franklin, Dangerfield, Beams, Pavlich, Martin, Chapman, Zorko <Saad, T.Adams>

$43k in the kitty!

Can get Sam Fisher or Matt Suckling in for either of Lake or Malceski.. Strong run home, etc.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: Ringo on August 06, 2012, 01:51:10 PM
Have you had a look at Jack Grimes as a target for lake or Eski averaging over 100 last 4 games. may allow you to increase cash if you go Lake. 
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 06, 2012, 02:38:33 PM
Mm.. Not a huge fan. Especially with Fisher and Suckling around the same price.. Think I may just sit on my trades for the week and use them if I lose my matches
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 06, 2012, 06:25:13 PM
Sit boy sit!

Looking good this week but looking even better after your well earned rest when you still have those 2 trades to use when The General makes his inevitable appearance.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 07, 2012, 01:22:45 PM
mm I suppose.. Just think by doing a trade now could be the difference between winning and having a week off instead of losing
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 09, 2012, 06:28:01 PM
Buddy buddy buddy.. Do we trade or do we hold??
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 10, 2012, 08:40:40 AM
Have a few options up my sleeve, please click on the link below and help my team out!
At the moment in thinking of getting Suckling in for Sammy Shaw. I can't make myself trade out Buddy!

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,66339.msg858897.html#msg858897
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 10, 2012, 02:29:24 PM
chapman out too.. my fwd line is in shambles!

Buddy, Chappy, Adams and Sexton! :(
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 10, 2012, 02:33:03 PM
Lucky you don't have Tippett.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 12, 2012, 01:48:59 PM
Extremely lucky I didn't trade! Will cost me all my league games but the guys I were looking at such as Fyfe and Suckling didn't make it or we're subbed. I feel like I have learnt a valuable lesson here today!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 13, 2012, 12:44:22 AM
made top 4 in all my leagues but took a loss for the first week of finals with a decimated forward line.. in hindsight a trade could have been well used to help me miss the donut that I had but I still have my two trades and plan to use them to get myself in the best possible position.. thinking if franklin isnt named this weekend may be a blessing in disguise
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: Ringo on August 13, 2012, 09:34:49 AM
Well done festy - I was in elimination finals of all  but 1 of my leagues so used my final 2 trades and won 3 of the 4 elimination finals. So the motto is use trades when needed. Did Franklin to Beams and worked for me.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 13, 2012, 10:37:16 AM
Those trades MUST be used this week!

Enjoy pressing that trade button for the last time.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 13, 2012, 06:01:23 PM
Ellis > Carazzo with 2 trades or Ellis > Suckling with 1?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 13, 2012, 07:36:37 PM
Few options..

Malceski > Newman, Gibson > Stevie J
Gibson > Burgoyne, Ellis > Heppell/ Suckling

Where do people think I should use my two trades?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 13, 2012, 07:41:04 PM
Must use both trades.

Which order would you start these 4 - Lake, Eski, S Shaw and Ellis?

Also, if Chappy misses again (calf may mean 2 - 3 weeks - if it was a calf) then maybe get SJ up front with one trade and see what's left for back upgrade.

Depending upon you stash of cash could you get Birchall?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 14, 2012, 12:23:40 PM
in order I would have put them the same as you - Lake, Malceski, Shaw and Ellis

1 chapman > stevie j, s.shaw > mackie, fisher, rance?
i think chappy will be right, they gave him til the last minute to get a plane over last friday night to play so surely it must just be a rest

2 sexton > lee, s.shaw > birchall

easiest way to get birchall in, but i do have to make two trades no matter what

3 ellis > tunbridge, sexton > m.johnson

freo have a relatively easy run home - richmond (H), north, demons (H) and gives me a bit of flexibility to my team in case of late withdrawls etc.

4 zorko > stevie j, s.shaw > duffield, fisher, rance, mackie?

people have been saying to trade zorko although has a very good run of games with port and the dogs (H) to come in last two rounds!

5 s.shaw > hanley

like i said has a good run in the last two games of the season. adcock may be a better get though!

if franklin isnt named to play...

buddy > sidebottom, ellis > birchall or

buddy > stevie j, ellis > carazzo

these are pretty much my options, so what do people think?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 14, 2012, 12:32:17 PM
i like the look of this..

B: Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, Waters, H.Shaw, Birchall, Lake <Malceski, Ellis>
M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Jelwood, Boyd, Priddis, Dal Santo <Gibson, Couch>
R: Cox, Jacobs <Stephenson, Redden>
F: Franklin, Beams, Pavlich, Dangerfield, Chapman, Zorko, Martin <Saad, T.Adams>

0 trades, $1,000 remaining
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 14, 2012, 01:09:52 PM
$1000 wasted!!  ;)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 14, 2012, 02:58:43 PM
contingency plan with chapman a possible out is..

Chapman > Sidebottom
S.Shaw > Suckling

otherwise my trade for the week is

Sexton > Couch
S.Shaw > Birchall

although i do like the look of this with Cooyou being promoted to finish off the year..

Saad > Cooyou
S.Shaw > Carrazzo

what do people think?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 14, 2012, 03:53:15 PM
adams > casboult
or
saad > couch

to get

ellis > carrazzo?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 14, 2012, 04:09:37 PM
I don't see the point of getting Carrazzo now as it will leave you with a very expensive defensive bench. Wasted IMO.

All depends upon your league requirements and selections on Thursday.

You may be forced to ditch Chapman or Buddy.

Hold for GF if you can.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 14, 2012, 04:47:14 PM
Well the fact is I need two trades if I'm going to upgrade anywhere and I would rather Carrazzo over Birchall.. If Chappy or Buddy doesn't play it will just make the decision easier.. Doesnt worry me if my defense bench is too expensive. In fact this is almost a plus!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 14, 2012, 06:08:51 PM
Yeah, I guess you think that way because you are a 'back coach'!  ;) :P
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 14, 2012, 07:16:40 PM
doctor told a funny :P cheer me and get out from this god forsaken coaching role!!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 14, 2012, 08:07:42 PM
One thing I'll do when I make my debut and mark the ball on the siren is deliberately kick it long to reward those who have faith in me.

Can't stand it when they limply return the ball to the umpire with no regard whatsoever to us hard working coaches.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 14, 2012, 10:54:41 PM
Número Uno: get Carrots in!

Much more consistent than any other backmen that I don't already have
If chappy does succumb to injury a Suckling/Fisher, Stevie J combo will be on the cards

Who is the best defender out of this mob..
Fisher, Rance, Mackie, Hurn, Houli, Hanley, Suckling..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 15, 2012, 08:45:14 AM
Interesting fact - no one I'm playing this week has Franklin. God I hope he comes back with a ten goal haul!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 16, 2012, 02:59:56 PM
here chappy chappy chappy

here buddy buddy buddy

thats a good boy, get selected now, dont make me trade you..

I'LL DO IT, I SWEAR TO GOD I'LL DO IT!!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 16, 2012, 04:47:08 PM
Both playing. According to me!  ;)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 16, 2012, 07:03:08 PM
 8)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 16, 2012, 07:03:54 PM
Both playing. According to me!  ;)

YAHOO!! means that saving trades last week wasn't futile.. what to do what to do..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 16, 2012, 07:04:32 PM
what do you think i should do doctor??
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 16, 2012, 07:14:51 PM
Option 1 -        Malceski > Hurn, Johnson, Hanley, Suckling

Option 2 -        Lake > Duffield, Fisher and above

Option 3 -        Sexton > Couch, Malceski > Birchall

Option 4 -        Saad > Casboult, Lake > Carrazzo

Option 5 -        Saad > Couch, Ellis > Carrazzo

What do you think??
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 17, 2012, 12:59:13 AM
Hurn > 100 3 / last 10!
MJ > 100 3 / last 10!
Hanley > 100 4 / last 10 BU2 in 40's and 2 in 50's!
Suckling > 100 3 / last 10 with 4 under 50!

BIRCHALL > 100 7 / last 10!

CARRAZZO > 100 5 / last 8 since injury!

I like option 3 of those you present.

You have premiums like 6 mids / 2 rucks / 7 fwds and short 1 in defence.

OR wait a week if you can win wothout trading.

Losing Eski for Birchall likely to get on average only 15 - 20 points extra. May be better waiting a week.

Depends upon how tight your league matches are.

I would go for broke just to avoid egg on my face by being over and out with trades to burn.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 17, 2012, 08:33:26 AM
Only reason I looked at Carrazzo is because he is much more consistent than Birchall.. Hasn't had too many games below 90!
While with Birchall the 3 he hasn't tonned up have been 40s - 60s

Carrots - Bombers, GCS, Saints
Birchall - GCS, Swans, Eagles
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: mpmac on August 17, 2012, 12:30:27 PM
I need help! After Treloar and Aaron Hall are both out I need to upgrade Haynes of GWS. I was thinking of trading out Toby Greene (I have Gibson as my spare) and bringing in Couch as back up to the back up. That leaves me $558k in bank - options are B Harvey. Pearce (freo) Roughead, Zaka, Petrie, Hawkins, Hale, Zorko, Bennell, Wright (Adel) Chapman Whitecross Martin Reiwoldt Fyfe. I would prefer a DPP as that would add some flexibility which I currently dont have. I am leaning to Wright. Thoughts I need help! I have 4 trades before today! Cheers
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 17, 2012, 01:03:18 PM
I need help! After Treloar and Aaron Hall are both out I need to upgrade Haynes of GWS. I was thinking of trading out Toby Greene (I have Gibson as my spare) and bringing in Couch as back up to the back up. That leaves me $558k in bank - options are B Harvey. Pearce (freo) Roughead, Zaka, Petrie, Hawkins, Hale, Zorko, Bennell, Wright (Adel) Chapman Whitecross Martin Reiwoldt Fyfe. I would prefer a DPP as that would add some flexibility which I currently dont have. I am leaning to Wright. Thoughts I need help! I have 4 trades before today! Cheers

what is this? :P

do you have a link to a page where i can see your full team? then i might be able to see all of your options
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 17, 2012, 08:57:06 PM
Went with the Ellis > Carrazzo, Saad > Couch trade... Hoping it pays off, Saad looks to have started the week well though :S
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 19, 2012, 07:56:02 AM
Not looking like a good pair of trades for this week.   :(

Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 19, 2012, 02:14:43 PM
Yeah very average! Good thing is im still around the mark in a lot of my games.. Fingers crossed!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 19, 2012, 07:40:54 PM
wow ablett saved my ass big time! won 4 out of 5 leagues and the one i did lose was by over 200 points so not much i could do there..

2379 was just enough! bring on next week and no trades left! :S
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 20, 2012, 09:58:00 AM
Martin and DNS hurting a lot of us big time!

Just glad you don't have Cloke hey?

Good luck.

Hopefully Buddy's back, Pav plays and The General stays away from Adelaide.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 20, 2012, 02:22:24 PM
Hopefully that changes this week! :) n
NDS v GWS and Dustin against the bombers.. I'm banking on Carrazzo and Scotland to hit back hard too!!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 20, 2012, 03:04:59 PM
Then you'll be looking at 2750 this week!
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 20, 2012, 05:09:15 PM
3163*
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 20, 2012, 09:18:07 PM
Playing one of my best mates in two leagues this week.. Let me know who you think will win!

Me v. Opponent

H.Shaw v. Birchall           -
Waters v. Mackie            Y
Scotland v. Dempsey      Y
Lake v. Yarran                 N

Jelwood v. Thompson      -
Dal Santo v. Hayes          -
Pendlebury v. Swan         -
Priddis v. Murphy            N

Cox v. Maric                    -
Jacobs v. Giles                -

Beams v. Sidebottom      Y
Chapman v. Johnson      N
Dangerfield v. Lewis        Y
Zorko v. Cloke                 Y

5 v. 3, Think I just have him pipped at the post ;)







Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 26, 2012, 09:06:56 AM
Looking very strong against my mate! 1885 with 7 players to come!! He has 1760 with 6 to come :)
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 26, 2012, 07:37:55 PM
2510.. really good week for me
had a sublime start to the week however gibson and sammy shaw showed their true rookie colours and lowered my predictions of a 2600+ week

hopefully selwood pavlich and lake come back into the team and give me a full strength line up and HOPEFULLY the general doesnt rear his ugly head.. i have the cover but im getting sick of these late withdrawls..
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on August 30, 2012, 07:22:53 PM
Who to field for the Grand Final out of

Malceski v Cats, Lake v Lions, S.Shaw v Giants?
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: tor01doc on August 30, 2012, 11:34:46 PM
Lake.

Less chance of sub I reckon.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: Ringo on August 31, 2012, 07:27:29 AM
Lake for me as well - Just concerned with Shaw playing GCS may not get the possessions.
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: felsty on September 02, 2012, 07:18:59 PM
BOOM!

won all four grand finals :)) wrapped...
will do a bit of a write up later in the week! :D
Title: Re: FELSTY'S 2012 SC TEAM THREAD - Team Completed!! Please read and comment!
Post by: Jay on September 02, 2012, 07:30:24 PM
Congratulations Felsty :D