Pass for me, his injury track record is a massive turn off. D7-D8 are usually two of your weakest players so you don't want to be using them too oftenWould rather pay the extra for Shaw and Doch or pick Rance for a similar price.
I know it's a risk, but you just cannot say no to a bloke who will play inside mid and is able to be picked as a defender. Averaged 28 touches this year and loves the contested ball. All I can see is points points points.