Kareem for all the points you mentioned.
Noah has the personal accolades and still helped in some way if he was playing a stinker, Roy played a lot of stinkers in his time during his prime.
ok interesting. I wont say what side im on yet.
does the other side have a valid argument though?
IT no, Roy and Noah are closer so could be argued either way.
Another for in Kareem's corner is perceived value of the position he plays, you could say very good PG's are more readily available, whereas big's with Kareem's skill come along once in a blue moon.